Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  

To Wash or Not to Wash - The Question

Recommended Posts

Right then. I've been on a YouTube binge for the past few weeks watching various videos by a wargames painter and her videos have made me question the way I paint my precious Imperial Guard for 40k (here's the link to her channel). Sacrilege, right? Not so. After seeing one of her camouflage videos (and then watching all of her other videos on the topic), a thought dawned on me: should I be washing these guys after I'm done stippling on their colours?


A little backstory should be given before I throw pictures at you. I've always liked the German Flecktarn camouflage pattern and decided to use it on my Imperial Guard troopers. Luckily, there was an article about stippling on the internet that I had found and the pattern clicked. So many years ago... Anyway, at the time, I figured you wouldn't be able to see if there had been wash used or not so none was ever used. After having watched these videos, it's time to figure out if this needs to be readdressed.


My first reaction is to scream "No!" at you until you go away as I have many guardsmen already painted up in Flecktarn. My more sane reaction is to agree to this washing as the models could use some shading in places; eg, around their cargo pockets, between equipment, where the tunic closes on itself, and around some of the tunic piping. Here are the pictures for reference. These are old pictures as they still feature the paper towel background I was told not to use.








The question, after whether they should be washed, is what colour wash should be used? Spectre Miniatures has a gorgeous tutorial on how to paint Multicam (which everyone should check out) and they use Athonian Camoshade - an olive green wash by Citadel. A brown shade was the first thing to come to mind but Flecktarn features more green than brown shades of colour. Perhaps a black wash would work better - thinned, of course?


So, yeah. I'm leaning towards giving them a wash but don't know what colour to choose. Maybe a thinned all-over wash and then a recess and pin wash? Any help would be appreciated. Also, I apologize for the bad lighting. It would be neat if you could see the Lieutenant's cigar in his left hand.

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Brown washes are pretty darn versatile. I vote wash, but, pick where to wash, what color wash, and how-thinned carefully. 


Washing is a good way to get general shading of nooks and crannies done fast. It is very easy to over-wash, which for some paint jobs, isn't necessarily bad. It just isn't ideal for nitpicky detail either. 


If you wash a green base with brown, you'll end up with a kinda olived green, with brown shadows. That could be pretty good. If you want to stay green, you need to use a dark green wash. 


Stippling and being covered by the wash? Depends on the stipples and the wash. I actually like doing some stippling-like splotches for dirt on occasion, and using a somewhat thin wash on top of it. The effect can smooth and dull the stipples, but not remove it. Washes rarely cover something entirely, if they are on a flatish surface. Sometimes, if I have fudged a joint between two colors in a crease, I will cover it with the wash-shadow for a color. Only works when the colors are somewhat similar, and I need a heavy bunch of wash. 


Place the washes where you want them. You can take them and simply use them as very very thin paints too. And if you mess up on putting them in the folds for shading, you haven't messed up the figure overall. 


I am pro-wash, but not pro-all-over-wash. Pick what color goes where, and how shaded you want it first. You can always re-stipple if you find the effect too dull afterward. 

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

@Cyradis Follow up question.  You talk about picking what color goes where (which makes a lot of sense of course) but is there a general rule as to what wash colors work well with basic base coat colors?  I know brown washes (hello Agrax Earthshade) get used a lot as washes since, well brown, looks like shadow anyway, but didn't know if there were certain "rules" for things like blues, reds, greens, yellows, etc.  Obviously its dangerous to lump things like "blue" or "red" into one category since there's so much variation even within the one color, but didn't know if there were general rules or not.


Obviously washes have some pretty good uses, especially for those of us that paint wargame armies and thus, have lots of minis to paint, but not being certain much of the time as to which colors I should be using for the wash is probably the biggest thing holding me back from using them more.  (That, and I'm still trying to get good at blending and shading/highlighting anyway for those figures that I do want to stand out from the crowd a bit.)

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

A bottle of wash is sorta like a bottle of paint. You can "slop and glop", pin wash (line the wash exactly where you want it), thin paints with washes, thin washes with water, etc. etc.


However, your paint jobs are great. Don't bother with washing your completed miniatures. For future painting, you can always "slop and glop" wash over zenithal primer or undercoat, because it takes little work. Maybe consider washes for your next army, or special units. 


fyi, Military Green wash and Mid-Brown washes will be in the Army Painter Quickshade Ink (wash in eye droppers) in June 2017. If you want individual bottles, also consider Secret Weapon Miniatures. Not sure which green or brown would work best, but you can always write to Mr. Justin of SWM, send him a link to this thread, and ask his opinion. Also, The Miniatures Page and Lead Adventurers have forums for military figures. Good luck!

  • Like 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't paint armies, so I am not sure exactly what effect you are going for. Typically, I go with brown base, dark brown wash. Green base, dark green wash. And so on for other colors. When I think of army colors, I think of beige and olive greens. So I would likely do brown and dull green base coats with dark brown washes to start out. 


Where it gets trickier is in yellows (which I find challenging) because you may want more of a brown shadow, or maybe an orange shadow. 


Reds you could argue for darker reds, maroons, browns, or even blacks. 


You can always test color combos on a piece of paper or aluminum foil before hitting the figure. It will give you a general idea of how colors react with each other. 


If you want to get super fancy, there are techniques with using blue or green washes on red bases, or purples with yellows, but those are typically glazed instead of washed - similar, but without the intent of filling nooks and crannies. Washes are for nooks and crannies mostly. 

  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Asking people here if you should do a wash is sort of a loaded question. Some are going to say "yes" before you finish the question because they have it so ingrained in their brains that the answer could never possibly be "no."


Others will not be happy until every model in your collection is lined with black, has ten shades of your darkest color, and has the very tiny toppest tips of every surface of the mini brought up to a spot of white.


But looking at your pictures, my common sense tells me, emphatically, no, do NOT wash these guys. At least not the two I see attached here. They already have deep, dark shadows and lines. A wash would either be too much or simply be wasted, since it's likely you could not see it. These guys might need a little highlighting. But more shading? No. You have that covered.


  • Like 12

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Othikent
      I did these guys a few months ago.

      I challenged myself when I painted these guys and avoided using washes. I'm very happy with the turnout.
      I'd love to hear what you all think.
    • By Jasper_the_2nd
      I've never been much of a fan of GW.  I mean the first fig I ever painted was GW, but that's because my friend (who was also the store owner) gave it to me for free (Come on, try it, the first one's free....).
      And I played some Bloodbowl back in the day (should really finish my Chaos Dwarf team one of these days...only been a decade or two).
      But I never really got into anything GW was making. Style wasn't what I was looking for, or the price point, or whatever.
      So then last week I was in Montreal for the GP (great time, too bad the race itself was soooooo boring). Was visiting a friend who lives up there and we wandered into the rather impressive GW store in the Eaton Centre.  Took a look around and caught sight of this:

      Apparently a new edition of Age of Sigmar is coming out this week, and these guys are a faction.  Or whatever the different groups are called.
      I thought, "Those are pretty cool!  Flying stuff.  Steampunky.  I like."
      Then we left.  And I went and marshaled for 3 days (the support races were better, btw).
      Then we met back up on Monday.  And I was still thinking about the cool steampunky flying ships.  So we went back and I picked up the starter. (they have 2 bigger flying ships too, but ouch, not cheap).
      So, this is what they look like when you open the box:

      Oye! Lots of bits.  Looks like everything has options (they have a very detailed assembly guide, quite impressive).  Options that presumably follow rules.  Rules I'm not sure I'll ever read, let alone play. 
      But I may check with the local store; I think they had some folks playing something GW.
      So that's all I've done with them so far, but figured I'd post and get the WIP started. These may take a bit to get going.
    • By paintybeard
      Compared to some of their other models the 40K Imperial Sentinel is ALMOST a reasonable price.
      So for some reason I decided to do one in World War 2 German camouflage:

    • By Geoff Davis
      I don't usually paint Warhammer miniatures, but there is a local painting contest which has very specific rules so I figured why not.  I've never entered a painting contest before, so there is no time like the present.  I've decided to carry on with my experiments in object source lighting and apply wht I've learned so far in this project.  One of the big challenges will be doing the OSL in the metallic armour of the knight.  I've never tried that before.  The two figures are "Neave Blacktalon" and "Wight King".
      Here is my planned layout.  The white line is to align their line of sight so they are looking each other in the eyes.  The source of light will be a big glowing rune on the ground in between them.   I chose these two figures becuase they both have cloaks that are blowing in the wind, but they are blowing in opposite directions.  That means that when they are facing each other, the wind direction is consistent.  I intend to make the grass be bent over in the same direction as well.  The wind is blowing from the wight towards the knight.  I am very tempted to name this project "Fus Ro..."  That might not be genre appropriate though. 

      I had some in progress shots of the base but I lost them somewhere.  Drag and drop error, probably.  I used milliput to make the rocky base.  I used the base of another rocky miniature to make impressions to give it texture.  The wight's foot is incorporated into his base, so I incorporated his whole base into the milliput mass.  I sculpted the runes/rock circle into the milliput and then added sand to it.  In the crevices.  I made my first big mistake at this stage.  I added the grass tufts too.  I should have waited until after I primed the whole base and then painted the ground where the grass would be attached.  My thinking was that the grass would look better if it was highlighted with the OSL effect in the same way as everything else.  However, it has proven very difficult to get paint through the grass tufts to make them shadowed underneath.  Other than that, I like the way it turned out.  I prepainted the whole base using the stone greys triad.  I highlighted the base with the greys and added white to get the areas that would be hit by the light from the rune to be brightest.  Today I spent the morning painting the OSL effects onto the base.  This lets me make sure the OSL on the figures and on the base will line up with each other and also be the same colours.
      I am using these for the OSL effect:

      Here is where I am at so far.  The figures are beside the base on their cork handles so you can see how they will line up eventually.  I need to darken the areas around the outside edge of the base a lot more still.  It is actually a lot darker than it look in the picture already.  I added progressively Nightshade Purple and Brown Liner to the Stone Grey for the shadow areas on the base. 

    • By Glitterwolf
      I painted an OOP GW metal Stegadon for my Lost World Project and added Foundry Aztec Crew.
      WIP here:
      First some pics against neutral background
      And then some against my Jungle Photo Board.

  • Who's Online   37 Members, 4 Anonymous, 0 Guests (See full list)