Jump to content

ladystorm

Reaper Bones 4: Enthusiasm and Commentary Thread

Recommended Posts

14 hours ago, Goop said:

Can someone explain the below images to me? Anyone else feel that some of these sculpts are a little too WoW-looking?  I was really enthusiastic about pledging in for my first Reaper Core Set, plus some extras, but looking closer I'm not so sure. Many of the weapons look positively cartoonish, and the big smooth features remind me of HeroForge, and not necessarily in a good way.

Or are these just temporary images of incomplete projects?   

 

Modern mini aesthetics are more and more cartoony, even Reaper seems affected. It must be more profitable or the artists must enjoy working in that aesthetic more. It's either something you put up with, or something that forces you to go search Ebay for oldhammer lots.

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, pinkymadigan said:

Modern mini aesthetics are more and more cartoony, even Reaper seems affected. It must be more profitable or the artists must enjoy working in that aesthetic more. It's either something you put up with, or something that forces you to go search Ebay for oldhammer lots.

 

Can also look further back in the Reaper catalog. They still make a lot of their older style stuff. 

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/8/2018 at 1:49 AM, paintybeard said:

 

 

Yes, I'll sign the "Save the Dead Caribou" petition.

 

I keep going back to the latest update and getting more and more disappointed with the renders. They are perfectly decent figures, but somehow the svelte menace of the original artwork doesn't come across.

Full disclosure is that I've been disappointed in some way, shape, or firm with most of the renders generated since the campaign ended. I'm hoping it's just how the digital looks and in person they look better, but I'm not as thrilled with Reaper's digital renders as their sculpted greens. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are there some Bones 3 digital renders that we could compare with the finished product for reference?

 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Cyradis said:

Are there some Bones 3 digital renders that we could compare with the finished product for reference?

 

Possibly bones 3 Sophie, but she's a really soft mini. I'd have to go back through the previews and my actual minis to see, but I'm not remembering as many renders in Bones 3, though I do remember being disappointed with several of them, like Sophie and the Valkyrie from the Pretty Deadly set. 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's iffy. For monsters, I don't mind 3D renders of monsters as much (like, i've seen Jason Wiebe's tyrannosaurus rex in person at the last ReaperCon, and it looks just fine, has all the detail i could want).

The turtle and zombie shark also looked pretty good to me

 

but humanoid renders seem to, as someone else put it, go into world of warcraft-ish cartoony style. I'm not sure why this is. maybe it is the sculptors. I will say that Jason Wiebe's frost giantesses are not bad, i just miss the caribou. So maybe it does come down to the artist doing the sculpting

 

i mean, i definitely prefer Julie Guthrie's dragons over the T'rauk that came out, simply because her scale design makes sense and is uniform while T'rauk's just...end. No transition from bigger to small, they're just laid onto the dragon as an afterthought. And i think if it had been a green instead of a 3D sculpt, more attention would have been paid to the scales. I bet that if Julie Guthrie took up 3D modeling, she'd still keep all the fascinating detail and personality she puts into her dragons. Or at least i'd hope so.

 

anyways, i think it boils down to the artists doing the sculpting, because i've seen 3D renders that look just as good as green stuff physical ones

  • Like 9

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Strange things happen when you look at different incarnations of the same thing.  Here's the art preview of the duelist from "Sophie and Friends":

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1513061270/reaper-miniatures-bones-4-mr-bones-epic-adventure/posts/2034198

 

She looks really, really smooth.  Like strangely so.  But if you look at the image of the metal version from the store, it looks like she's got a bad skin condition or maybe a lumpy primer coat.  http://www.reapermini.com/OnlineStore/duelist/latest/03867

 

Then there's the actual real metal version of the model that I have already purchased.  And she looks fine.  Better than fine, she looks closer to the concept art in a way.  So I think there's something that the render preview software does that doesn't quite look right, but in the end it doesn't have it any more.  Or at least, that's the way my eyes see it.  

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/11/2018 at 10:39 AM, pinkymadigan said:

Modern mini aesthetics are more and more cartoony, even Reaper seems affected. It must be more profitable or the artists must enjoy working in that aesthetic more. It's either something you put up with, or something that forces you to go search Ebay for oldhammer lots.

 

 

Is it related to the transition away from physical sculpting?  Perhaps the artists hired to do computer modeling are just more used to that style.  

I've been getting most of my minis from Ebay: really enjoying old ral partha and reaper models.  I can't afford to buy old school Reaper models retail at the moment.  There are still a lot of great Bones options in the old style that I plan on buying, but I'm feeling iffy about the number of new style sculpts in this Kickstarter package.  Perhaps if these new Blizzard style sculpts are really what people want, as you suggest, I can get the Kickstarter, keep the models I want, and sell the rest on eBay.

 

19 hours ago, Cyradis said:

Are there some Bones 3 digital renders that we could compare with the finished product for reference?

 


I tried using waybackmachine to figure this out, but the image is the same as the current version: not a lot of digital renders.  Most of the Renders that are on the page look pretty good, but they're mostly of large monsters.  The crusaders package looks pretty WoW-y though.  [I can't upload an image at the moment for some reason - will try again later]
Does anyone know how these models ended up looking?

 

Edited by Goop
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Weapon size etc is of course a matter of taste. Personally I'm not in love with those guard miniatures in the core set (nr 14 and 15, 416-418), though they are probably very useful for gaming. Bones already doesn't look as good for human sized minis imho, so making the detail not as intricate and weapons more robust is preferable to me opposed to having bendy weapons or soft/mushy detail.

 

I don't really support the notion that modern miniatures are more cartoonish and video-gamy, I feel like there are plenty of sculptors who go with a more historical take on weapons and gear. 

 

And as others have said, the rendered turntables look unnaturally smooth and too perfect. Imho that's the medium and the fact that it's not photographed in reality. My Zbrush stuff also always looks kinda weird, because if something is smooth, it's really, really perfectly smooth in a way real things aren't. Also, if lighting and shader aren't super fine tuned and time-consumingly calculated, a rendered image will always look more like a cartoon than reality. 

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I do think that the WoW-style stuff actually works better in Bones material than the non-cartoonish stuff. It is chunkier instead of sleek, and Bones gets all warped on sleek stuff. I like the WoW-style stuff (only played obsessively for 5 years) but I like other styles too. Other styles do better in metal and resin, in my opinion. Mostly it seems like the knights and bandits that are getting cartoonish, and actually seem a bit like the space marines that are overly clunky too. **shrug** There is a variety. I don't need to complain here. 

 

@Nunae kinda beat me to it - human Bones are Meh. Fattening them up helps. 

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Personally, I don't like minis that have been rendered very much. I particularly don't like them in metal. In bones they're fine, they work better in that medium. But I feel like the metal minis that have been made from an actual sculpted mini have a lot more detail and personality. Their hair is finer, the details more proportionate, the crevasses aren't weird blank spaces, their faces aren't too symmetrical.

 

I mean, I still like them, but they don't have the same feel as hand sculpted minis. :shrug:

Edited by redambrosia
  • Like 10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I kind of like the WoW style (played WoW and EQ for quite a while in my younger years) so I don't have a problem with the renders. I also think that while the "cartoony" style might not look as elegant or accurate when painted (not that any of mine look elegant or realistic when painted!), the oversized bolder weapons makes them easier to differentiate on the table. 

 

Me: Okay, I am going to sneak around and stab that guard

DM: Which guard?

Me: the giant Axe one, not the sword one

 

And you can just glance up and tell, ya know?

 

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I don't mind the renders, and like a lot of the 3D designed minis, I think they have grown a lot since the first few in Bones 2 (stiff poses, etc)

Also, I totally agree with the thought that the new Crusaders look like something out of Warcraft: specifically, they remind me of the Scarlet Crusade.

 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Crowley
      A DCC RPG boxed setting for Lankhmar, officially licensed by the estate of Fritz Leiber. Adventure with Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser!

       
      There are three basic pledge levels:
      The PDF pledge level includes an electronic edition of the final boxed set. (Obviously there will be no box!) This level does not include any physical rewards, add-ons or stretch goals. The boxed set includes the core boxed set as described above. All electronic stretch goals (PDFs) will apply to this level. Some of the physical stretch goals will apply to this level, generally those that fit in the box. The final level includes the boxed set as well as the "print pack." All electronic stretch goals (PDFs) will apply to this level. All of the physical stretch goals will apply, as well. Those that do not fit in the box will be shipped in a separate "print pack." See below for more information on these stretch goals.  
      Stretch Goals
      DCC Lankhmar continues a long tradition in RPG gaming, and we want to do right by the estate of Fritz Leiber. The stretch goals associated with this Kickstarter will help create an even more amazing tribute to the world of Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser.
      Stretch goals fall into three categories:
      PDF stretch goals that all backers receive Print stretch goals that can fit into the boxed set, which will be included with any pledge that has the physical boxed set The "Print Pack," which is a printed collection of the stretch goals which don't fit in the boxed set Here is a rough outline of possible stretch goals, which may evolve as the Kickstarter continues.
      At $40,000: Cleared! We will add a new Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $60,000: We will print the poster map larger (included in boxed set)
      At $80,000: We will add a second Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $100,000: We will add a supplement called "A Dozen Lankhmar Locations," which will provide information, maps, and floorplans on setting adventures in a dozen famous Lankhmar locales (including the Silver Eel!) (PDF for all backers; print copy in the boxed set)
      At $120,000: We will add a third Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $140,000: We will add a supplement called "Random NPCs in Lankhmar," which will provide tables and information for generating random NPCs that your PCs can encounter in Lankhmar (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $160,000: We will add a fourth Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $180,000: We will add a Lankhmar-themed three-panel Judges Screen (PDF for all backers; print copy in the boxed set)
      At $200,000: We will add a fifth Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $220,000: We will add a cloth map in the boxed set (print copy in the boxed set)
      At $240,000: We will add a sixth Lankhmar adventure module (PDF for all backers; print copy in the Print Pack)
      At $250,000: We will add send Michael Curtis to Houston for a week to research the Fritz Leiber archives in the University of Houston. We anticipate this may result in a new product of some kind to be delivered to backers of this Kickstarter, but exactly what we'll discover in the archives - and what product may result from it - can't be determined until Michael sets foot in the archives!
    • By BryanBorgman
      Hello everyone. I am pleased to announce the launch of Stars Reach spaceship miniatures on Kickstarter.
       
      Stars Reach spaceship miniatures are designed by Twilight Game Designs TJ. I am managing the Kickstarter for them (including promotion and pledge management).
       
      Twilight Game Designs is offering three new fleets that can be used in games such as 5150 Star Navy by Two Hour Wargames, Squadron Strike by Ad Astra Games, Starmada by Majestic Twelve Games, and more. The three fleets are: the Koreth Imperium, the Trazari Colonies, and the Human Commonwealth.
        Stars Reach spaceship miniatures will be cast in pewter in the USA. Production and fulfillment will be provided by Acheson Creations. This Kickstarter is live now and will end at 10:00pm EST on Sunday, April 30, 2017. Follow the link and pledge today! The universe is counting on you!   https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/twilightgamedesigns/stars-reach-space-ship-miniatures  
      Please spread the word and feel free to ask me questions here or on the Kickstarter project page.
      - Bryan
       
    • By SamuraiJack
      About this project
      Code Zero is a 32mm miniatures skirmish game set in a futuristic alternate universe. Players take control of a small squad of troops, broken up into fireteams, competing with each other to achieve one or several objectives and complete their mission. These combat situations usually take place within a theater of war, on the borders along the core worlds of various factions. These dangerous worlds and systems which are on the outskirts of secured core sectors are known as Code Zero's. The owners of the territories tend to change hands monthly since many of them are inhabited by second class citizens, those trying to survive and make a living in harsh future.  
      Code Zero is designed to create a cinematic feel of gameplay, while reflecting the dynamic ebb and flow of the battle that can happen within any given engagement. We do this by utilizing an action/reaction system, allowing both players to interact in a method keeping everyone engrossed with the battle. Utilizing alternate activations along with a different method to resolve reactions this can create some unique situations  
      The first of our miniatures for this universe are digitally sculpted, 3d printed and cast in high quality resin.
       
       
    • By pcktlnt
      Project: Captain Redbeard's Pirate Dwarves
       
      About this project
      Avast me hearties! Splice the mainbrace and beat to quarters, that galleon is bilged on her anchor and ripe for the picking! Bring us alongside Gibbs. Boomer, get ready on the gun! Pete my boy, are you loaded? Hefty, Sharktooth, Deadeye, follow me! Gyaaarh! 

        This project is to fund production of a pirate dwarf crew, a set of unique miniatures forming a warband of adventuring buccaneers for skirmish gaming or a unit of mercenary fighters in a larger dwarf army. 
      They are 28mm metal miniatures, sculpted by Mark Evans, who produced all the dwarf sculpts in our previous kickstarter. 

        This time we have decided to offer only one pledge level, with all stretch goals being free additions to the set. If you want multiple sets just increase your pledge amount accordingly. 
      Pledge price includes FREE SHIPPING in the UK and discounted shipping of just £2 for anywhere else worldwide.
       If successfully funded each backer will receive one each of Captain Redbeard's crew plus any applicable stretch goals- 
      1. Cap'n Redbeard   2. Bo'sun Gibbs   3. Deadeye Dan  
      4. Hefty Hawkins      5. Slick Willie         6. Sharktooth Jack
      7. Pigwash    8. Little Pete      9. Boomer Svensson and Swivel Gun
       The Captain himself. As gnarly a swashbucking, treasure-hungry dwarf as you could ever hope to meet. He'll fight anyone and anything if there's a promise of doubloons which makes his crew a useful mercenary force to bolster any dwarf army (just don't pay him in advance).
       The captain's trusted Bo'sun, often found leading boarding parties or manning the ship when the captain takes a raiding party ashore.
       His aim is as good with his axe as with his pistol, as many an enemy has found out
       Avast behind! The crew will often mutter about hefty, but not within earshot of him. If you have a door to kick down, a bear to wrestle or a sandwich to eat, he's your man.
       The general opinion among the crew is the Willie fancies himself, with his goatee, ponytail and feather in his hat, he cares a bit too much about his appearance.
       Sharktooth is just a thorough git, a complete thug with a pair of wicked short knives that earned him his nickname. 
       Rumour has it that Pigwash was once captain of his own ship, nobody knows for sure and nobody likes to ask because of that big axe he carries around.
       The smallest of the crew, some say he's overcompensating but with his blunderbuss he can clear a deck or blow a dwarf sized hole in a city gate.
       He's got you covered, the swivel gun is small enough that the crew will often take it ashore for some extra firepower. 
    • By Suden
      This looks like it could be fun. Pre-painted minis with an odd choice for scale, 65 to 85mm. The early samples do look good though:
       
       
       
  • Who's Online   18 Members, 3 Anonymous, 0 Guests (See full list)

×