Jump to content


Carnacki the Ghost Finder

Bones Supporter
  • Content Count

    1260
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

1988 Adventurer

1 Follower

About Carnacki the Ghost Finder

  • Rank
    Godlike

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Montreal, Canada

Recent Profile Visitors

1005 profile views
  1. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    How do you feel about multiple projects being open by the same creator

    I still don't like it. Actually I like it even less now than I did when this conversation started on April 30th. I've come to the conclusion that multiple open projects is always a bad sign, no matter who it is. Period. And I don't care about arguments that "you have to do this if you are a business because you can't wait when a project has delays if you have more in the pipeline." Find another solution. Also, companies that do this a lot and get away with it (CMON) keep drawing potentially reluctant backers to yet one more project by offering large numbers of expensive KS exclusives which function by exploiting FOMO: "I want Bloodborne because the miniatures look cool but if I want to really enjoy it I have to go all-in for hundreds of dollars on a game I've never played and may not enjoy but my fear of missing out overwhelms my reason." And a happy Sunday morning to you all.
  2. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    BattleSystems - Fantasy Terrain 2

    I have a bunch of this stuff. It's great but it was expensive ... I might be able to stay out of this unless they do ruins. Oh crud, I think I see a ruin in the background ....
  3. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Hellboy Boardgame kickstarter by Mantic

    Got my box a week ago -- I am very happy with the contents. Seeing Mignola's art come to life this way is really enjoyable and the miniatures are better than I expected. The tutorial was engaging. I haven't played a game like this and liked it. There is an exciting rumor on BGG that the pledge manager will be reopening to allow backers to add the new expansion "The Wild Hunt" to their orders (presumably wave two shipping?)
  4. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Cthulhu Wars: the Daemon Sultan - The Final Onslaught

    Still waiting for Onslaught 3 so nope for me. Arthur said they said they wouldn't launch this until they had completed Onslaught 3 fulfillment.
  5. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    How do you feel about multiple projects being open by the same creator

    The funding goals for Kickstarter projects are also increasingly fictions. I know of a couple of board game projects that lost money even though they raised much more than their funding goal.
  6. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Planet of the Apes The miniatures Boardgame

    In my opinion: The real question is why it funded in the first place. Ironically called "WYSIWYGames" when all they were offering were a series of images of game boxes and components without any game substance behind it. People pledged because the images on the page looked slick, professional and enticing at first glance, and then people realized there was no substance to back up the images. And people are dropping their pledges because the [...] who are running this dead project haven't done the intelligent, sensible (and expected) thing are cancelled it (do they even know they can? Do they know how Kickstarter works?), which is making even their dedicated supporters go ??? and drop their pledges. The poor communications and behaviour of the project creators during this have been baffling and this last gesture should put the nail in the coffin for anyone thinking of ever giving them money.
  7. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Bloodborne : 24 hour EB

    I have an EB but am looking for reasons to drop it. For example, the FAQ says the scale is 28 mm - the Hunters are 28 mm to the eye, so overall these monsters won't be as big as they might seem.
  8. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    How do you feel about multiple projects being open by the same creator

    If I have money in a KS that is pending fulfillment I absolutely will not give the same creator money for a new project, even if they have successfully fulfilled projects in the past. I just won't do it. While I do see delayed projects (and, for that matter, multiple open projects) as a warning sign, in the final assessment it has nothing to do with them. It is my decision. There are lots of projects I was considering backing and didn't for this reason (CAV, a whole bunch of Petersen Games projects) and I don't regret a single decision not to back a project. For example, I was very happy with Cthulhu Wars Onslaught one and two, and backed three, but avoided The Gods War, Planet Apocalypse, and Hyperspace, because of my personal rule. And right now I am very frustrated by my CW 3 being in an increasingly disturbing limbo while they run CW 6 (CW 4 and 5 were run earlier this season). I would only be more frustrated if I had backed any of their other projects.
  9. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Cthulhu Wars: Onslaught Three

    I'm staggered at how prolonged the fulfillment of this project is taking. Apparently there is a "computer glitch' with their shipper which means that over 300 orders have been languishing for a couple of weeks now, with no announcement of a solution in sight. (Mine is one of them.) They have resorted to "backer only" updates so the shipper doesn't see them, and Arthur has called the shipper a "lemon" in the comments. Meanwhile, during the fulfillment process, they have run two shorter CW related projects and now the "Final Onslaught" project. It's baffling that after so many projects they come up against problems like this.
  10. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Planet of the Apes The miniatures Boardgame

    Exactly. Between that and the wonky pledge level costs -- if you can't do basic math then why would I give you money?
  11. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Hellboy Boardgame kickstarter by Mantic

    Fantastic work. I really appreciate your response!
  12. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Hellboy Boardgame kickstarter by Mantic

    Thanks for posting those images Brianuk. I will be waiting a while for them to arrive. The quality of the miniatures looks great and you have made the details pop already! What are you using to prime the plastic, if you don't mind me asking?
  13. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Planet of the Apes The miniatures Boardgame

    While I do not wish to be unduly negative, I am frankly surprised this funded at all, and will be even more surprised should be stay funded. It's been treading water for a couple of days.
  14. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Planet of the Apes The miniatures Boardgame

    The main game has three trees plus a bunch of other stuff for $110 bucks. If you wanted more trees it makes more sense to just get two base games and go bananas with the extra monkeys. The previous project they ran was a staggeringly unsuccessful zombicide clone. I am also wary of Kickstarters with licensed Fox IP (ahem cough prodos AvP...) as just bad luck.
  15. Carnacki the Ghost Finder

    Planet of the Apes The miniatures Boardgame

    Am I just stupid or does the "all-in" pledge (not early bird) cost five dollars more than the backer's choice pledge plus the reforestation add-on?
×