Jump to content

Pingo

Giant sizes, how have they changed?

Recommended Posts

Since D&D 5E giants are back to the 2E sizes ( Hill 16', Stone & Fire 18', Frost 21'),  perhaps Reaper can dust off the enormous classic looking giants and get them in white plastic for Bones KS III.

02579: Blorg, Hill Giant - 02599: Frorigh, Frost Giant - 02647: Gunther, Fire Giant

This was in the "Bones We'd Like to See" thread. I didn't want to derail, so here's a new thread.

 

How have giants changed over the years in D&D and other games? Why were they changed? Do the changes make certain minis obsolete, assuming one is strict about base size and scale?

 

Inquiring minds want to know.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Since D&D 5E giants are back to the 2E sizes ( Hill 16', Stone & Fire 18', Frost 21'),  perhaps Reaper can dust off the enormous classic looking giants and get them in white plastic for Bones KS III.

02579: Blorg, Hill Giant - 02599: Frorigh, Frost Giant - 02647: Gunther, Fire Giant

This was in the "Bones We'd Like to See" thread. I didn't want to derail, so here's a new thread.

 

How have giants changed over the years in D&D and other games? Why were they changed? Do the changes make certain minis obsolete, assuming one is strict about base size and scale?

 

Inquiring minds want to know.

 

 

Yes always in need of more giants

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, the sizes for most of the 2E giants are huge which is 12' + to 25' except for the wood, verbeeg and firbolg which are large, and the storm which is gargantuan. So for game purposes I suppose that it would be ok as long as they were based correctly, but I don't play 5E so I'm not sure about their rules. I actually like the 3E change to the fire giant, since they have always been listed as being built like dwarves. I never did understand Reaper's take on the frost giant though, except Frorigh and Frulla, but hey maybe frost giants in their world had dwarfism.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to admit that I haven't really paid much attention to the height and weight listed for individual giants from 3.x on. I think probably because most of my players came from 1st and 2nd Edition, and we already had a firm idea of what they looked-like in our minds. So i just snatched up minis that fit the concept of the giant in question; did he need a club, a spear, a sword, and was he the right race of giant? Then I was happy.

 

I've also always kept a wide open mind when it comes to scale for giants. I find my players don't generally notice the difference between one mini that is greatly larger than their PCs and another, unless it is HUGELY larger. They seem more preoccupied with whatever weapon the giant is carrying. The more dangerous-looking, the more impressed they are.

 

For me an issue comes up only in the opposite direction, where something is supposed to be a giant - and impressive - but the mini is just not that much bigger than the PCs.

 

So, for me at least, scale creep may have muddied the waters when it comes to giants, but not in a way that has been really detrimental to my games. I did have a longterm player who did sometimes comment when, say, a new ogre mini appeared more "true-giant" sized than the old Ral Parthas, because he was afraid that the difference in minis would be reflected in-game, but what we settled on was to just understand it was all about base size. Unless a rule stated otherwise, in 3.x, base size generally determined reach, so as long as the giant had the right base size, he was happy. So that's still generally the standard I go by, as we play Pathfinder, and it remains relevant.

 

We don't use a grid when we play Pathfinder, we measure. And sometimes we just eyeball the bases. So having the right base size is the most important thing for us.

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's see, I'll just list the ones from the edition I play (AD&D 1e): 

  • Ogre (if one considers Ogres as part of the Giant family): L (9'+ tall)
  • Verbeeg: L (8 1/2' - 10' tall)
  • Firbolg: L (10 1/2' tall)
  • Hill Giant: L (10 1/2' tall)
  • Stone Giant: L (12' tall)
  • Fire Giant: L (12' tall)
  • Formorian: L (13 1/2' tall)
  • Mountain Giant: L (14' tall)
  • Frost Giant: L (15' tall)
  • Cloud GIant: L (18'tall)
  • Fog Giant: L (18' tall)
  • Titan (if one considers Titans as part of the Giant family): L (18'+ tall)
  • Storm Giant: L (21' tall)
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm with dsmiles on this one. I always remember the main D&D giant types being in 3 foot steps. Storm (21), Cloud (18), Frost (15), Fire & Stone (12), Hill (10). Ok so the Hill is a bit off the 3 foot pattern. Anyways! More giants would be nice. Especially some more female giants. Has anybody ever made a female Hill Giant?

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm with dsmiles on this one. I always remember the main D&D giant types being in 3 foot steps. Storm (21), Cloud (18), Frost (15), Fire & Stone (12), Hill (10). Ok so the Hill is a bit off the 3 foot pattern. Anyways! More giants would be nice. Especially some more female giants. Has anybody ever made a female Hill Giant?

 

I always used Frulla Krung (02622) with different paint jobs. Only recently has anyone addressed the idea of female giants at ALL.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In Pathfinder, Storm and Cloud giants are a 60mm base, all the rest are 40mm base, which seems short to me considering enlarge person puts you up to a 40mm base..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I'm with dsmiles on this one. I always remember the main D&D giant types being in 3 foot steps. Storm (21), Cloud (18), Frost (15), Fire & Stone (12), Hill (10). Ok so the Hill is a bit off the 3 foot pattern. Anyways! More giants would be nice. Especially some more female giants. Has anybody ever made a female Hill Giant?

 

I always used Frulla Krung (02622) with different paint jobs. Only recently has anyone addressed the idea of female giants at ALL.

 

I wonder why it took so long. The all male races generally produced by mini makers is really annoying. There's no shortage of "elf chicks". It's like if it's not an anorexic blonde sculptures generally just don't know what to do. But I'm starting to rant. ^_^

 

Back on topic. Having really gigantic giant minis just isn't practical. In my world setting I just have the all giants types (which are just different ethnicities of the same species) stand roughly twice the height a human (and halflings stand at half the height of a human). So the Reaper giants are pretty much perfect for that scale.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure what giant I'll use it for but I'll be getting my Gomagg from Mierce before my 5th edition session ends. Can't wait for their reaction to that one. While crazy big in our scale he only comes out to about 30' or so.

 

pic for those not familiar

 

47da3365a17459549470196c5c0d3865_large.j

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't remember which supplement it was, but D&D introduced a bizarre scenario involving some rather atypical fire giant women.

I can't say they'd ever make the cover of Vanity Fair, but they did look better than your usual "ogres painted black," or "giant black dwarves."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In Pathfinder, Storm and Cloud giants are a 60mm base, all the rest are 40mm base, which seems short to me considering enlarge person puts you up to a 40mm base..

 

Pathfinder and 3.5 both had the same trope of 25mm being "medium," 40mm being "large", and either 60 or 75mm being "Huge" with other critters varying here and there.  To them, the base size and getting reach was important.

 

I'd have to doublecheck on 3.5 and pathfinder giant heights, but the bases are something I am fairly confident about.

 

Also, Monkeysloth:  That is a big giant.  Wow. 

 

And Ral Partha (Ironwind) have a female giant.  It's one of the few early ones I can recall.

Edited by Darkmeer
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I'm with dsmiles on this one. I always remember the main D&D giant types being in 3 foot steps. Storm (21), Cloud (18), Frost (15), Fire & Stone (12), Hill (10). Ok so the Hill is a bit off the 3 foot pattern. Anyways! More giants would be nice. Especially some more female giants. Has anybody ever made a female Hill Giant?

 

 

I always used Frulla Krung (02622) with different paint jobs. Only recently has anyone addressed the idea of female giants at ALL.

We had quite a debate around here, shortly after Yephima was introduced maybe a year ago-ish, about female giants and what they could look like and do. Female hill giants were brought up back then, too, as I recall.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In Pathfinder, Storm and Cloud giants are a 60mm base, all the rest are 40mm base, which seems short to me considering enlarge person puts you up to a 40mm base..

 

?

 

In Pathfinder, base sizes are mostly not specified. To the extent that they are, the sizes are "fits in a cube X squares on a side" and the default square size is 25mm/1".

 

Are you referring to the sizes of the pawns in the various Bestiary boxes?

 

Anyway, for Pathfinder (all heights are for males, females, where different, are "slightly shorter and lighter"):

 

Cloud Giant: Huge, 18' tall, 5000#

Fire Giant: Large, 12-16' tall, 7000#

Frost Giant: Large, 15' tall, 2800#

Hill Giant: Large, 10' tall, 1100#

Stone Giant: Large, 12' tall, 1500#

Storm Giant: Huge, 21' tall, 12000#

Cyclops: Large, 9' tall, 600#

Ogre: Large, 10' tall, 650#

 

Marsh Giant: Large, No height or weight specified

Rune Giant: Gargantuan, 40' tall, 25000#

Taiga Giant: Huge, 20' tall, 10000#

Wood Giant: Large, 14' Tall, 1200#

 

Ash Giant: Large, 10' tall, 1200#

Cave Giant: Large, 10', 1000#

Desert Giant: Large, 15', 2000#

Jungle Giant: Huge, 17', 4000#

 

Cliff Giant: Large, 14', 1300#

Ocean Giant: Huge, 22', 15000#

River Giant: Large, 10', 900#

Slag Giant: Large, 14', 3000#

 

For me, I wouldn't obsolete a figure if the size changed. It would become a different type, or just get placed on a base of the appropriate size if that seemed necessary. (I will often use "sabot" bases -- removable, attached with magnets -- if I need a figure on a different sized base). But I consider minis to be pretty counters having no special effect on the play of the game other than coolness.

Edited by Doug Sundseth
  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never understood how an ogre and a hill giant are the same size but have such a huge CR difference. Seem silly to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Thrym
      Hellborn Troll
      from WizKids' Nolzur's Marvelous Miniatures
       
      I stopped at AC Moore today and picked up one of the FolkArt Pickling Washes I didn't have while my wife was shopping for school play costume materials.  Nearby I found FolkArt Ultra Dyes and picked up two colors to check out; Purple Rain and Pucker Up (a yellow).
       

       
      I have enjoyed using the Glass Enamels with the long cure time before and thought these might work similarly.   I decided to wash my troll with the Purple Rain to see how it comes out and goes on.
       

       
      It's fairly thick out of the bottle but I might not have shaken it enough.  It was taking forever to dry so I hit it with some Testors Dullcote to speed the process and reduce the shine.  It's glossy like inks.
       
      Next, I used Reaper Blood Red to give him the Hellborn look I wanted.
       

       
      Then I pulled out Reaper Violet Shadow to get his hair, teeth and claws darkened.
       

       
      I then went back over the boney bits with the FolkArt Ultra Dye.  It'll put the glossy touch to the claws and teeth.
       
      I am quite happy with him so far.  
       
      Stay tuned and Enjoy!
    • By vutpakdi
      Traveling Encounters volume 1
      Compelling 5th Edition Challenges For CR1 to CR5
       
      This small project is to fund a collection of little encounters that can be dropped into an existing adventure for low level adventurers.  I backed his previous project for alternate character backgrounds, and he delivered the PDFs early.
       

       

       
    • By ChaoticBlues
      The Grand Duchy of Reme awaits!
      Starting in 2002 Necromancer Games began populating its Lost Lands campaign setting one adventure at a time. The Grand Duchy of Reme is the region home to classic adventures released by Necromancer Games for D20/3.x and Frog God Games for Pathfinder, Swords & Wizardry and Fifth Edition. 
      More than 10 adventures have brought life to the Grand Duchy of Reme. The Lost Lands Campaign Sourcebook funded in January is expected to be over 700 pages and all of them are full of information. By necessity each region was described broadly, but there are still a wealth of history, politics and other details to be explored, experience and expanded in the Grand Duchy of Reme. 
      The Grand Duchy of Reme is a system neutral hardcover volume designed to be useful for campaigns independent of system preference. Specific details that affect the characters in the Lost Lands there are System Encounter Books. These companion volumes are softcover (or PDF), that contain reference stats for use with the Region book along with detailed encounter tables for the region.
      Additionally, 3 classic adventures previously unavailable for Pathfinder, Swords & Wizardry, and Fifth Edition are back. These are offered as either softcover add-ons in backerkit or as free stretch goals in PDF (see reward sidebar).
      Mock-up of Grand Duchy of Reme. Final release will differ slightly The city of Reme itself is ancient, with world-spanning trade — the eternal citadel of the Loreclans, where the ashes of legendary barbarian kings reside. This land lies near the slow collapse of the nearby Empire of Foere, and the rise of Bard’s Gate to the East. The Rhemish watch these events with cold eyes rather than concern, for they live in vast regions that devour invaders. Their land is eternal; their people can be forced back to the plains, but in the plains they can abide for as long as need be. They are — as a people — the ultimate hunters. The fall of Foere is like the fall of an antelope upon the plains; the rise of Bard’s Gate is little more than the stepping-up of jackals before the body. The Grand Duchy of Reme simply waits and watches — for Reme is the dwelling-place of the world’s wolves.
      Reme is a unique fantasy civilization whose structure is determined by the one overriding fact of its geography — the country is a vast, grassland plain. The realm is dominated by the culture of the ancient Loreclans: the urbanized and settled ones, and the nomadic clans of the interior. The Loreclans owe a certain fealty to the Dukes of Reme, who are the final arbiters of the ancient law of the plains, but between the Loreclans and the Dukes there are also the mysterious Pashtars: arbiters, judges, and mediators who roam the plains where their service takes them.
      The city of Reme, of course, is one of the wonders of the world of the Lost Lands, home of powerful spell-casters and perhaps the greatest mercantile and war fleets of the Crescent Sea. It is also, however, steeped in the culture of the vast plains of the interior. It is a place where assumptions are dangerous, for it is no standard fantasy environment — it is a culture that will be entirely new and foreign to your players, a place to truly explore as well as adventure.
       
       
       
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/froggodgames/the-lost-lands-grand-duchy-of-reme/description
    • By Lidless Eye
      Here's some shots from the penultimate session of our D&D game.
       
      The party finally confronts the Sewn Sisters.
      The tiles are from "Dwarven Forge" and "Secret Weapon".  The tables, chairs, and most props are from "Mantic:Terrain Crate", with the cauldron being from an Old Glory Crones set.  
      The Scarecrow & Leomon (Half-Elf Paladin) are from "Reaper Bones".
      The rest of the party are 3D prints, from HeroForge, Desktop Hero, and Miguel Zavala.
      The Sewn Sisters are 3D prints from DarkRealms.
      Everything was hand painted by myself.
       


       
      Cradle of the Death God.
      The tiles are Dwarven Forge.
      The party are 3D prints, with designs from Hero Forge, Desktop Hero, and Miguel Zavala. (One is a Reaper Bones piece)
      The Soulmonger is a 3D print designed by Miguel Zavala.  The God That Never Was is a 3D design by Duncan "Shadow" Louca.
      Everything was painted by myself.  I also added LEDs.
       

       
       
       
  • Who's Online   28 Members, 2 Anonymous, 211 Guests (See full list)

×