Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  
Arikiel

Giant's mass to CR ratio

Recommended Posts

I was lining up my larger humanoids in a row and made an observation, relating to the  new larger giants coming out (in Bones 3), mass, and CR (using 3.x D&D/Pathfinder rules). So I thought I'd share my thoughts. :)

 

It seems that for basic humanoids (without regeneration or other fancy rules that boost up their CR beyond their base mass) there's generally a fairly even progression. Which is there's a +1 to CR for every 5mm of mini height (1ft in game) beyond the base 28mm (5'7") mini size.

 

Based off CR added to any class levels.

+0 CR â‰ˆ 30mm (6ft.) Standard size for human mini

+1 CR â‰ˆ 35mm (7ft.) "Advanced" template Orc Boss (77064).

+2 CR â‰ˆ 40mm (8ft.) Bugbears (77015).

+3 CR â‰ˆ 45mm (9ft.) Ogres (77105). I'm assuming the Bones 3 Ogres will be about the same size.

+5 CR â‰ˆ 55mm (11ft.) Giant-kin (Bones 1 Fire/Frost Giants).

+7 CR â‰ˆ 65mm (13 ft.) Hill Giants (77313).

+8 CR â‰ˆ 70mm (14 ft.) Stone Giants (77336). Ya they're a bit lightly built but it roughly works.

+9 CR â‰ˆ 75mm (15 ft.) Frost Giants (Bones 3). This seems to be about how tall they'll be.

+10 CR â‰ˆ 75mm* (15 ft.) Fire Giants (Bones 3). *As they're so wide they're a bit shorter they otherwise would be.

 

So what do you think? If there's any merit to my line of thinking I hope we see some 85mm Cloud Giants (CR 11) and 95mm Storm Giants (CR 13) some time in the future. Bones 4?

Edited by Arikiel
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like your theory, but CR is driven by the game designers, so it's hard to predict how the mini will affect it. It seems like a pretty reasonable rule of thumb for your game.

 

(Interestingly, a 70mm Stone Giant should be about 8x the mass of that 35mm Orc, and happens to also have 8x the CR. Sure, you might call it coincidence, but I say it implies that a 140mm giant should be about CR 64.  :upside: )

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like your theory, but CR is driven by the game designers, so it's hard to predict how the mini will affect it. It seems like a pretty reasonable rule of thumb for your game.

 

(Interestingly, a 70mm Stone Giant should be about 8x the mass of that 35mm Orc, and happens to also have 8x the CR. Sure, you might call it coincidence, but I say it implies that a 140mm giant should be about CR 64.   :upside: )

Oh! I hadn't noticed that. As you point out that wouldn't really work at the higher levels but it is a fun coincidence.  ^_^

 

I just thought it was fun that there was something of an even/scaled advancement. I can hardly wait to receive the new giants to get an actual view of them. Mostly I was considering this to decide what I could field my smaller Bones 1 "Frost Giants" as. Looks like I'll just use stats something comparable to a Cyclops or Ettin and call them "Giant-kin".

 

I also like how the Trolls I have (CR 4-6) are Ogre sized (CR 3) because it makes sense that their CR would be higher then their base mass because of the regeneration and all that jazz.

Edited by Arikiel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Maledrakh
      From the first Bones kickstarter, or rather, a purchase I made soon after since I did not add on the "Fire Giant Warriors" subset.
      As I have written earlier, I am grinding through getting the older versions of the Giants painted, as the newer versions are both 1) better detailed, and 2) a lot larger. The idea is that if I do not get the older ones done before I start the newer versions, they will never be touched again. Which would be a shame, really.
      This is the only old version Fire Giant I have, as the ones from Bones 3 and out are the new size and design.

      I went with red skin and firey hair and beard.
      The red is new Citadel Screamer Pink, Wazdakka Red and Evil Sunz Scarlet. The steel is Scalecolor Black Metal, Army Painter Plate Mail Metal and Army Painter Shining Silver. The gold is Vallejo Model Color Brass.
       

      ...and Char Donaye is only one wicket away from retaining the Ashes...
       
      77179 Fire Giant Bodyguard
      Reaper Miniatures, Bones 1 KS 2012
      Sculpted by Jason Wiebe
      Bonesium PVC.
      60mm round lipped base
      available from reapermini.com
    • By Brianuk
      Loved these minis from the Kickstarter. I thought they would be taller but still enjoyed painting them. These are nearly done, I just need to highlight again and then tidy up all the things I ignore on smaller models because they don't show up... 
       
      Also need to do a snow effects base. 



    • By Brianuk
      Bones 4 hill giants and Bones 3 ogres, along with Garghuk the Bones Black sample figure. All painted with citadel contrast paints. 
    • By PurpleLlama
      I haven’t posted in a while.  Been mostly painting terrain for the past 8 months or so.  Finally getting back to some minis.
       
      So I picked up the Wizkids frost giant last fall to paint up as Harashnag for my Storm Kings Thunder campaign.  He had been sitting around for a while and I finally got a chance to get him painted.  
       
      The right arm actually wasn’t glued in very well so I was able to paint with it out of the way for the most part.  As usual with these Wizkids pre-primes, I didn’t clean up any mold lines though I probably should have this time around.  C&C welcome!
       
       




    • By Lidless Eye
      A set of Frost Giantesses from Bones 4
       

       
       

       
       
       

       
       
       
  • Who's Online   12 Members, 1 Anonymous, 108 Guests (See full list)

×