Jump to content

Blackhawk

Basing preference: Plain or detailed?

Recommended Posts

In a gaming Facebook group I'm a part of, someone asked a question - do you prefer plain black bases, or detailed terrain bases?  The question seemed obvious to me.  When I started painting miniatures, bases were either broccoli or square, and a plain black base was looked at as an unfinished base.  At the very least you sanded and drybrushed or flocked them.

 

The answers in the group surprised me.  Out of dozens of answers, the overwhelming majority preferred plain bases.  They felt that detailed bases took away from the miniature, and that it was counter-immersive to be playing a game and have a dwarf with a snow base, and elf with a forest base, and a fighter with a desert base wandering around in the same stone floored cave.

 

It was also notable that the vast majority preferred round bases.  Some of those that did didn't just prefer them, the vehemently hated square bases.  I wonder if some of the change in views on bases are a result of the popularity of the pre-painted D&D minis line over hand painted miniatures over the past decade?

 

Anyway, it was an interesting enough discussion that I thought I'd bring it here and see what people had to say.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I greatly prefer playing with figures that have scenic bases and making scenic bases even if they "clash" with the current environment that the character in use is in. To me, I do the base to set the mood and COMPLETE the miniature (usually it's a very personal base meant to help tell a little story of where they are from or what they did), I feel that plain black bases distract and make the figure incomplete... My own personal opinion.  I also prefer 25mm (1 inch) square bases as they actually give a little more room to pose figures. I use mine for gaming (D&D), which is why I don't use bases bigger than the 1 inch for medium sized.  

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What Uber said, except that since I never gamed with square bases, I prefer the freedom of round bases in composition.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably scenic would be my preference as a rule, but I think Ub3r mentioned potential clashing of bases in a more standard RPG setting, or even some tabletop skirmish/war games.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like scenic bases.

 

And prefer hexagonal. Most of my gaming (when I do it) is on hex maps.

 

What?! :huh:

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For miniatures wargames, I use whatever basing standards are required by the game. For the games that I play, that's usually rectangular, multi-figure bases.

 

For RPG figures, I use a size that works with the figure, biased toward bases that will fit (for "Medium" figures) into a 1" square. But I typically try to go a bit smaller than 1" in at least one dimension so that the terrain on the map can be at least partially seen.

 

For display figures, I'll use whatever works with the figure.

 

In all cases I do some sort of work on the bases: rocks, sculpted boards, tile, flock, bushes. I have some 1/285 armor figures where each base is a simple diorama -- The four bases of bicycle infantry can all be put together to show a bicycle platoon travelling down a dirt road with trees, the halftracks show dismounted figures in a hasty fighting position, some using the halftrack for cover, and so on.

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For my painting cause I like it minis, Scenic bases all the way. I have no preference for size or shape of base. For my board game minis, I leave the bases fairly plain. They're just going to be thrown in their Plano box after all.

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like mostly plain bases. I am not fussy about the shape of the base. Round, square, hex, oval, rectangle...are all fine.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not surprised that a Facebook group would prefer plain. The majority of people out there who play with minis at all would be RPGers, and the majority of them probably don't even own the minis they use; they probably pick them from their GM's big box of pre-painteds.

 

Conversely, I am not surprised that so many here prefer scenic, since that's pretty much what we do here.

 

When I paint minis to put up on the table for sale, I base depending on who I think is most likely to buy them. If they are specifically for wargaming, I go ahead and go to town, since those dudes usually want the scenic stuff and take better care of things. If they are generic, and likely to be picked up for an RPG, I tone it down and tend toward tougher materials, like styrene or solid resin bases, or similar. That's because those are more likely to be dropped, kicked, knocked across the table in a fit of gamer rage, or have Mountain Dew spilled on them.

 

For my own stuff, it depends on how far down the road I am thinking, in terms of use. I might base for whatever setting or terrain I believe the mini will see the most in-game, or I base per the theme of the mini itself.

  • Like 8

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I fall between the two camps. I don't mind plain black bases, but I prefer a little bit of groundwork of some sort. I'm not fond of over-detailed basing though; I feel that it tends to compete with the figure, and I reserve that sort of thing for dioramas or figure vignettes.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like plain round bases.

 

I think most flocking type bases look cheap and often detracts from the paint job (especially when the flocking is unpainted...dks sez if you put it on the base, paint it).

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I prefer decorative bases, even if it's impossible for the terrain on the base to match the terrain the figures are on.  I mean, it's not like I expect the figure to always carry the weapon the character has in-game, or always to be in the same pose as whatever action the character is taking in-game.  The pose and base detail help to contribute to an atmosphere/aura to say something about the character, I think, or his "native habitat."

 

The base I go with is often dictated by the game I play (e.g., Iron Kingdoms and its lipped bases at 30, 40, 50, or 120 mm diameters), but when I have a choice, I tend to go for 25mm round bases for "normal human" sized characters.  Since I have an abundance of them, I make a lot of use of leftover Mage Knight and HeroClix bases for figures that are a bit too large for 25mm rounds.  Any larger than that, and I tend to go with whatever is the smallest base I can fit the figure on without too much fear of it falling over.

 

I'll use plain bases when I have to, for the sake of getting things done quickly, but I prefer decorated bases when I have the time and resources.  I just think they're more fun that way.  I realize that sometimes I've gone a bit overboard with trying to cram things into a decorative base, to the point of elevating the figure a bit too much or adding too much clutter to be practical.  I try to be better about that now.  :)

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think you will find that there is a difference in basing preference between RPG gamers and skirmish/wargamers.

 

Bases help unify a cohesive force in wargaming and add a lot of character. For warbands/ armies, scenic basing is obviously the superior option. This is my preferred game type.

 

In RPGs circumstances vary widely; each character is unique and each player has their own interpretation of what their character should be, leading to a patchwork of basing options.

 

Personally, I fanatically prefer decorative bases - even in RPGs. IMHO a mini in a RPG is glorified placeholder. Unlike wargames where WYSIWYG (what you see is what you get), characters often vary considerably from their mini depending on circumstance (weapons and armor change as characters adapt to different environments over time). Because of this, I say go all in - make the token as differentiable as possible from the others, and let it convey a.... story or aspect of personality of the character. A dwarf on a snow base will convey a different feeling than the same dwarf on a lush jungle base. If you start adding in references to backstory then the miniature really comes to represent the personality of the character rather than their current material state.

 

That said, I love making terrain too, and for a while I pondered the idea of mounting my minis on clear acrylic bases so it would appear as though they were standing on whatever terrain was below.

 

As far as basing shape goes, I'm inconsistent. I generally pick whichever base looks best on the mini. sometimes they have vertices, sometimes they don't.

Edited by vulture
  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By Morihalda
      Several friends helpfully pointed out that before I started throwing wild ideas at Ma'al's base, I should probably practice them somewhere else first. That base is on my February list, so I gotta get practicing!
       
      Blightfang:
      - Completely covered giant base.
      - No integrated parts. I chopped 'em off.
      - Water with a "live" edge!
      - The first dragon I owned, blessed upon me by my first Box of Goodwill group, and a perfect fit for a Silversage dragon.
       
      Narthrax:
      - Plain, round, smaller base.
      - Rocks from his original base are staying.
      - Probably no water.
      - He's just plain cool. He's gonna be my Boelen's python!
       
      I used PVA glue to put the cork together, and hot glued everything to the bases. Thank you for your sacrifices, peanut butter and pickle lids!

       
      I fell in love with Paepercut's youtube channel after @Clearman mentioned it in my Ma'al thread. Y'all. That guy is SO COOL. The vast majority of the things I'll be doing here are from his videos. And if I don't think they are, they probably still are because I'm forgetful like that.   Onward!
       
      Actually. Onward in a little bit. I gotta go check out the nearest store and see if they have distilled water for the next steps. Be right back!
    • By SGHawkins09
      The official arrival/departure thread for Round 2 of the Basing Edition of the Box of Goodwill.
       
      PLEASE make sure to post when you receive the box and when you send it off.

      Remember, NO CHATTER, chatter thread is here:

      Box of Goodwill, Basing Edition Round 2 - Chatter Thread


      SGHawkins09 - sent 2/16
      Keianna - arrived 2/20, sent 2/27
      Sylverthorne - arrived 3/1, sent 3/9
      NecroMancer - arrived 3/12, sent 3/15
      hungerfan - arrived 3/18, sent 3/23
      Ulfheathen - arrived 3/26, sent 4/2
      Aryanun - arrived 4/4, 
      hiddenone32 - new box arrived 6/11, sent 6/15
      Clearman - arrived 6/18
      Guildenstern - arrived 6/27, sent 7/2
      Shadowphaze - arrived 7/5, sent 7/9
      Generic Fighter - arrived 7/11
      Dilvish the Deliverer - arrived 8/8

      Dilvish the Deliverer - sent 2/26
      Wyvernfire - arrived 2/27, sent 3/10
      Chaoswolf - arrived 3/12, sent 3/26
      Knarthex - arrived 3/28, sent 4/13
      Paradoxical Mouse - arrived 4/16
      Dragoneye - arrived 8/8, sent ReaperCon
      Kangaroorex - arrived ReaperCon, sent 9/18
      Fire_Eyes - arrived 9/20, sent 
      Keianna - arrived 10/1, sent 10/10
      Pegazus - arrived 10/12
      SparrowMarie - arrived 10/24
      LittleBluberry - arrived 11/10
      SGHawkins09 - arrived 01/18/19
       
      Only two groups this time and they are fairly large so make sure to keep the boxes moving. Also you may notice Keianna is listed in both groups, this is intentional as she did not receive a box last time.
    • By SparrowMarie
      So I'm going to be making a diorama for a friend soon. I have a pretty solid idea of what I want to do but no idea how to go about it. I've never worked with cork before and am going to be using quite a bit of it. I want to pour water effects(?) into it but don't want the cork to soak it up. My questions are (photos to be added below for reference):
       
      How do I seal the cork so it won't absorb the resin water effects? Do I need to seal the wood I am basing it on as well? If so what is the best way to do that? What is the best glue to put the cork on the wood, sealed or not?  
      ETA: 
      How do I fix the small hairline cracks in the cork (not sure if they're visible in the picture)? Kind of related but what is the best glue for plastic to wood (I'm going to be putting the wood on top of a painted Tropicana lid)?  

    • By SamuraiJack
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/416262521/scenic-resin-bases-for-28mm-tabletop-wargame-minia?ref=discovery
       
      After a successful 1st kickstarter project earlier in the year I am back with a second.  
      This time I am looking to extend my existing range of 28mm scenic bases with 3 further lines. I already make bases as part of my business and have paved bases, lava bases etc. along with various bits of terrain in my range already. 
      Moonkraft is a fairly new start up and I am looking to add many many more goodies to what I already sell. I have a brain overflowing with ideas, the only trouble is deciding which to do 1st.  
      If you are like me and are a miniature painter and gamer, then you already know that a good base will give you miniature the finish you want and can really make or break a good bit of painting. Also this bit of modelling can be a little tedious and time consuming and if you are painting a new army those minutes soon add up and turn into hours.  
      I have created 3 new sets of bases, Rocky outcrops, Skulls and Rocks and my personal favourite Atlantian Temple Ruins. I need to raise just £500 for the moulding costs to produce all 3 of these sets of bases. which I will add to my growing range of terrain and bases. 
      The bases were sculpted by myself and I have made them in 3 sizes, 25mm, 30mm & 40mm so they should fit all the sizes you require.  
      The pictures don't do them justice.
      25mm Temple bases 30mm Temple Bases 40mm Temple Bases 25mm Skull & Rock Bases 30mm Skull & Rock Bases 40mm Skull & Rock Bases 25mm Rocky Outcrop Bases 30mm Rocky Outcrop Bases 40mm Rocky Outcrop Bases I do things the old fashioned way, no 3D printing or computer software, I build and sculpt, then I make moulds, then I cast. If necessary there may be a 2nd mould made to improve casting after any adjustments have been made, but this is a rarity as I am an old hand at the process.  
      The funds will be used for the silicone to make the molds (the expensive bit) and also go towards the resin. 
      Postage. We will be shipping the set out as soon as the funds come in and the prices are set to the following 3 zones: UK, Europe & Rest of World. Prices are based on Royal Mail to calculate the cost.
    • By Rat13
      I've made no secret about my opinions on Games Workshop. Though my painting box is full of their miniatures they were always bought second and sometimes third hand (I never wanted GW to get any of my money). Even my previous Cadians were bought from my local games store that has no affiliation with GW (I also know those sets and blisters came with the business when it was bought almost twenty years ago). Now I find myself in the unique position of building a Cadian army.
       
      My wife and I used to play weekly in D&D Adventure League but with the birth of our first child it looks like that won't be possible (We want to continue gaming at our current store but its a bit of drive and the kid is at the rolling stage so she doesn't want to be held or sit in her seat; she wants to be on the floor and we all know what gameshop floors are like). I've offered to watch the child so she can go or to switch off each week but she only wants to go together. Gaming together has always been part of our relationship, and she doesn't want to lose that. I couldn't agree more, its good to share a hobby with your spouse.
       
      That's when our friends started trying to recruit us to play Warhammer 40K with them. At first I was resistant but our friends get together often to play and in our area its always possible to find a game (Depending on the size it can be played fairly quickly in comparison to D&D too). After some discussion we decided 40K would give me something to paint, but it would also give us both something to play and eventually something to play together.
       
      Which brings us to this new project. Since I figured watching me assemble miniatures would be pretty boring I'm starting this thread right before I prime them. So here is most of my assembled starter set (I've got quite a few cheap sets of bits arriving over the next couple weeks and I'm not exactly sure what unit I'd like to create next so that's why I have so many unfinished figures).
       
      I'm still not a big fan of GW but having an excuse to see our friends more often is pretty nice. In a way we're kinda trading one gaming group for another (that sounds pretty mean but I think you understand what I'm saying).
  • Who's Online   24 Members, 0 Anonymous, 140 Guests (See full list)

×