Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Pingo

Digital, blocky "Minecraft" camouflage apparently much more effective than blobby camo

Recommended Posts

http://www.bbc.com/autos/story/20160324-the-story-behind-chinas-minecraft-military-camo

 

It sounds counterintuitive (and apparently was much second-guessed and delayed after its effectiveness was first discovered in the 1970s), but digital, square-based "Minecraft"-type camouflage is far more effective at visually disguising forms, both up close and at a distance, than traditional blobby-form camouflages.

 

Last September China held a massive military parade to celebrate the 70th anniversary of the end of WWII, showing off for the first time many military vehicles decorated with digital patterns of squares in four colors.

 

US Army Lieutenant Colonel Timothy R O'Neill, PhD, credited with the discovery almost forty years ago, shared his original test before-and-after photos with the BBC:

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/images/ic/raw/p03nxg80.jpg

 

http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/images/ic/raw/p03nxg7f.jpg

  • Like 10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's mainly because it's a semi-fractal pattern; the closer you get, the more detail of the camouflage pattern you see, meaning no blobs jump in or out once you get closer or further away.

 

It's not restricted to squares, but square fractals are a lot easier to make than blobby fractals. German Flecktarn is one of the few I know isn't square.

Edited by djizomdjinn

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

They've gone back and forth on this one a few times.  The most effective camo that I've encountered under field conditions was straight khaki, which is admittedly sort of a fractal pattern because the dust fragments and camo pigments are about the same size ("War in the Beige Lands" is a terrible book title).  The US army's digital camo turned out to be of limited utility:

 

camoflage-couch.jpg

  • Like 7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My opposition to digital camo vanished when I realized that if you had to choose between being invisible to spy satellites, night vision, digital cameras, binoculars, drones, and missiles OR being invisible to humans, the answer is kind of obvious.

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I bet digital camouflage would be improved if each square element was an oval instead.

 

No change to the centre point of each element, no change to the color, the ovals could be sized to cover exactly the same area as each square.

 

But ovals could be one of four randomly selected orientations.

 

I think the result would look more organic, might work better — at least be more acceptable to humans.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Canadian army has shifted over almost completely to CADPAT uniforms on our troops. They work crazy good in the broad range of terrain they were designed for, and not nearly so well in places like Afghanistan or Syria, where the terrain type changes swiftly, or is all something Canadians didn't plan for, like desert. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I play paintball, as soon as I switched to digi-camo I was almost invisible. I could just kneel off the trail behind minimal bush cover and as long as I didn't move the other teams players would walk right past me without seeing me at all. It's even better than the Ghillie suits some people wore. I even put it on to play hide and seek with my niece and nephew, changed my position (MGS style) so they could try and spot me, 3 times and they still couldn't find me.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I play paintball, as soon as I switched to digi-camo I was almost invisible. I could just kneel off the trail behind minimal bush cover and as long as I didn't move the other teams players would walk right past me without seeing me at all. It's even better than the Ghillie suits some people wore. I even put it on to play hide and seek with my niece and nephew, changed my position (MGS style) so they could try and spot me, 3 times and they still couldn't find me.

I played paintball back in the before times. Before anybody thought of adapting cattle marking guns and their squashy paint pellets. Back when we had to make do with copper coated steel. Solid metal.

 

Anyway, one time this guy showed up in some surplus Italian Army issue autumn fatigues. This was in the fall of that year. He simply dissappeared. At will.

 

Digital is good but having the right colors on is King.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To me, this is one of those things where truth is stranger than fiction.

 

Next thing we know, they'll discover that red ones really do go faster... :lol:

Don't be ridiculous.

 

Everyone knows it's STRIPES and FLAMES that make you faster!

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By TaleSpinner
      I was going to start a topic about my new journey into digital sculpting, but I decided that I didn't want this topic to be just about me.  I'll still give my story, trials, tribulations, joys, and frustrations, but I hope others will too.  This thread is then a place to discuss anything about digital sculpting. 
       
      If you are a sculptor, I want to hear your thoughts on it and your journey with it, or your reasons for avoiding it.  If you are a painter/collector, what are your thoughts?  What do you like about digital, what do you dislike.
       
      I'll leave it here for now, and come back and post my story and where I'm at in another post.
       
      (Do you guys think I should pin this, or are we getting too many pinned topics? Do we need a separate thread for 3D printing, or will this suffice?)
    • By planetmut
      Private Chapman has been in stasis for 1,538 days and awake for two. Private Chapman is wondering where she is, when she is and what her mission is. Private Chapman is also pondering why she hasn't been issued desert pattern armour.
       
      Private Chapman has just spotted something up ahead. Private Chapman's life expectancy is four minutes.
       
      (Again, sorry about the photos which were taken on my phone.)

    • By Watchman
      This is a continuation of a thread started in "More X-Wing Fun", covering stories for a start until some new pilots are trained.  I gave out "The Force Awakens" to a few guys for Christmas and Birthdays in the hopes of expanding the player base.  The group at the local game store seems to have vanished.  So continuing...
      This is the Rebellion News Network (R.N.N.)
      Watchman reporting from somewhere in the Distal Reaches.

       
                  We encountered a rather strange cosmic anomaly that has thrown us off course; no one seems to know our present whereabouts.  The emergency transmitter has been broadcasting our location since we lost our course lock-on. It has been only forty-five minutes but we have been informed of a locating beacon that has started transmitting a positional fix to home in on.  Evidently this is not a standard type beacon, not matching anything on the Galactic Navigational Charts…             We are, finally, approaching an uncharted planetary body…

       
                 We have been instructed to close all view ports before we land.  I am placing a Remote Optical Pad on the port that should pass all but the closest detailed external inspection. I plan to activate a Randomized Signal Receiver just before touchdown, and possibly obtain some external video…             So, a Military base of some sort: a Gozanti Cruiser taking off (?), and Y-wing bombers.  Looks like about two squadrons of Kihraxz fighters landing.  Here are two rows of Z-95s, which I am unable to determine how many are present. Looks like a standard type of base construction seen elsewhere.  Hmmm, there is no visible activity of any kind currently, which I can pick out, inside the installation.  
                  Okay we are going down and swinging around just past the base.           
      We have an interesting development, looks like I am picking up stray video signals close by from someone doing a visual scan of us.  They seem to be interested in our weapons mounts. Sorry guys nothing new or special here, same-o, same-o.
      Could this be a dual function base?  I see three Jumpmaster 5000s, an YT1300 and a HWK290.  Also an air patrol of Protectorate Star fighters. Okay feed was terminated.

                  I will complete the report when we liftoff.

       
      Watchman reporting,
      Good Day
    • By MojoBob
      I found this model somewhere on the internet, alone and uncredited, so I have no idea who made it or what it is or anything. People have suggested that it's a Kirby, whatever that is, with a human face pasted on.

      I like it, and I'll print about a dozen of them, and make up some stats to use them in my D&D campaign in some way. I'm leaning towards some kind of waddling tar-baby critter, but we shall see.

      The original model was only about 1.5mm tall, so I've rescaled it by 1500% to roughly 20mm.
    • By lexomatic
      Some friends are doing this, under their Infinite Dimensions Games, though I'm not involved. The Kickstarter will take place in March and is for digital files for 3D print. If I remember correctly there are no physical rewards. While people should hold off until the details of the crowdfund are released, my understanding is that the core set is done, any stretch goals will pay for the labour of doing the design/sculpting of those items only, so the core set would be ready as soon as funding period is over. 
      They have a Facebook and Instagram and more for lots of previews (but I'm not linking because I'm not sure what on those sites will break forum rules), and if anyone is attending BreakoutCon this year in Toronto, they will be there displaying.
       
       
       
  • Who's Online   16 Members, 0 Anonymous, 34 Guests (See full list)

×
×
  • Create New...