Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
Darsc Zacal

The Fantastic Worlds of Grenadier by Terence Gunn

Recommended Posts

This Kickstarter is for production and printing of a new edition of a book that the author had originally self published over a decade ago:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1155053944/the-fantastic-worlds-of-grenadier/description

 

I do have a few concerns about the way the Kickstarter is organized and laid out. I suspect the project creator has little or no experience with Kickstarter. No information about shipping costs and stating that there is no risk to backing their project, as well as a 60 day running time with an expected delivery date of only 3 months after the project ends all make me a bit wary.

I'm also concerned about him having the rights to use artists work from Grenadiers products in his book.

 

Having said that, the reviews I can find of his original book have generally been positive. It would seem interviews with a number of key people at Grenadier were missing, as well as several of their more well known sculptors.

 

So yeah. Tempted and interested, but also a bit wary. I'll be watching it to see if any of my concerns are addressed.

Edited by Darsc Zacal
Tag updated
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, he hasn't researched his own milieu very well. For instance, he says his book is the first and only book of it's kind, but there's a whole book about the Perry Brothers out there, just as one example.

 

Pretty sure there are others that at least talk about the sculptors, and many books about gaming in general that mention various miniatures companies.

 

GW toots its own horn all the time, and has published any number of books over the years about themselves.

 

And what's all this about Grenadier being the most innovative, influential and most expansive line in the history of ever? I love my old minis, too, but even at Grenadier's height, there were other companies competing with them that were putting out better product, and there were historical minis companies that had far more range than they did. Grenadier was important in its way, but I think we all know how much more influential Ral Partha was.

 

Too much hyperbole can put a brother off.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Self-publishing experience is better than nothing. He might still have the previous edition in electronic format, and I saw it on a search for $15.

 

Still working on it and First Created, so expect the usual delays!

 

Hmm. Wonder why he doesn't have an eBook or PDF pledge level. That's free money right there!

 

Search on the book. Seems like it was favorably received.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, he hasn't researched his own milieu very well. For instance, he says his book is the first and only book of it's kind, but there's a whole book about the Perry Brothers out there, just as one example.

 

Pretty sure there are others that at least talk about the sculptors, and many books about gaming in general that mention various miniatures companies.

 

GW toots its own horn all the time, and has published any number of books over the years about themselves.

 

And what's all this about Grenadier being the most innovative, influential and most expansive line in the history of ever? I love my old minis, too, but even at Grenadier's height, there were other companies competing with them that were putting out better product, and there were historical minis companies that had far more range than they did. Grenadier was important in its way, but I think we all know how much more influential Ral Partha was.

 

Too much hyperbole can put a brother off.

I had the same feelings as you when I read that. Hopefully the author can tone down the fanboyism and keep with a more even handed and factual account of the company.
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had the last edition, along with the cd with the images, and it was pretty well done. I don't recall it coming across as fanboy-ish despite what the campaign text might imply.  I think he would be well served to show some sample pages in the campaign as there probably aren't many who recall the last edition or know what he is doing. I hope it succeeds - I always enjoy the history of our hobby and the memories it brings.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A revised print edition of Terence Gunn's The Fantastic Worlds of Grenadier has gone live on KS!

 

It's a wonderful book that is chock full of company background, information, and history, as well as pictures galore. Oh, and it is only $35 per copy.

 

If you missed out on the previous print edition, you won't want to miss it this time around.

 

http://kck.st/28OQkTC

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Merged the new thread. A reminder to please check for existing Kickstarter threads before starting a new one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am usually quite supportive of small projects like this, but this project is terrible. The page layout is just a long text, which I, honestly, didn't have the strenght to read the first time (and I'd imagine others having same thoughts), and the text, honestly, just doesn't bring any value. I barely understand what I would be receiving if I was to support the project. The pledge levels? "Each pledge of $35 up to $140 will receive a book." it says in the description. But what will a pledge of $50 give, for example?

 

To be frank, this project needs to be cancelled, re-organized to be clearer, and then launched again. As mentioned above, pictures and reference-text of how the previous book looked like would help a lot. I am surprised that, when writing this, the project has reached already 15% of the funding. Imagine if the main page would have been constructed better.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sample pages, they need to be on the KS page though.

 

https://www.acaeum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?cache=1&f=10&t=15911&c=1

Totally agree. He should have at least a page or two up on the Kickstarter so potential backers have some idea of what they may be getting. What's showing looks pretty good. If I saw this book in a store rather than on Kickstarter I'd very likely buy it. It's the sort of thing I'd like to see from all the major old school miniature companies.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

+1 to what is said above. Those sample pages add a lot of value, and I'd be 100% more inclined to back out of those two sample pages compared to the main body of text of the KS project. Someone needs to have a chat with the creator and make arguments of how to improve the project.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 Agreed - based on a quick peek at those pages, I'd probably take a chance and back it if I had some cash to throw at it...But the KS pitch doesn't inspire much confidence.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thought I'd check in on this to see how it's progressing, and it's really not.

Sad to see as I was hoping someone would help the project creator reorganize his Kickstarter but it doesn't look like that's going to happen.

Again it's too bad, as the book is something I'd be interested in seeing if properly done.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By DragonWyrm
      The dwarf is an Eureka 15mm figure (maybe 18mm, can't remember right now). I brought him with other 15mm figures to see if they would fit as brownies, gnomes or dwarves. He fits all of the roles, so now I know where to get some small folk. I actually enjoyed painting him and the 15mm landsknechts (didn't photograph them) a lot more than I expected.
       
      The monk is an old Grenadier Figure, I think you can get him at Mirliton now. I speed painted him using a Zorn Pallet. It works well for anyone who is somber or drab, it can also work well for NMM.
       
      The figures on both sides are from Ground Zero Games, i think they are from the goth set. They can work as cultists, lords or even vampires. 
       
      The maid and the butler are from Wargames Foundry. I really like the sets. The rest is still being painted. With the maid I experimented in painting an impression of some lace or embroidery on her pink skirt. I tried to make the cup she holds look like bone china. 
       
      Everyone

       
      Back of the Servants
      This picture is closer to the real colour than the one above (thought it is still not perfect, with the monks robes not being as distinct in sections as they are)

       
      Feedback and Critiques are welcome and appreciated. 
       
       
       
    • By Orlando_the_Technicoloured
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/russrmc/animal-adventures-secrets-of-gullet-cove



      Painting Polygons

      NeW Animal Adventures Kickstarter launches January 28, 2020!

      Set sail for a mysterious portside city where magic and adventure await...

      21 brand new minis (including a Kickstarter exclusive!)
      Fully illustrated, hardback sourcebook with artwork from leading industry artists
      Collection of maps

      With a host of colourful (and questionable!) non-playable characters, compelling locations, and a collection of multi-part adventures, Secrets of Gullet Cove opens up a brand new universe for you to explore.

      Don't miss the Kickstarter launch at 4PM GMT/8AM PST on January 28th 
    • By SamuraiJack
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/awakenrealms/81524567?ref=evzsas&token=8eaedf7a&fbclid=IwAR0J91XxQUE6SE1HQcvjOr2oZnAZoneIL31yr6GnwV9G2yPSiVSP-0tCQzg
       
      About
      Welcome to the Great Wall draft page – the campaign is not live yet, but we will be gradually adding more and more information about the game here! We are incredibly excited to hear your feedback, so please let us know what you think. If it looks interesting to you - make sure to click the "Notify me on launch" button!
      The Great Wall is a new major board game from Awaken Realms (creators of Nemesis, Tainted Grail, Etherfields and many other acclaimed products). Players will take the roles of generals of an ancient oriental empire who lead the defence against ruthless hordes. You will need to gather allied advisors, manage your workers, recruit armies and, together with other players, raise and defend the Great Wall! As the game progresses, you will often need to co-operate or negotiate with other players, but make no mistake – there can be only one winner!
      This fresh worker (and soldier!) placement game for 1-4 players faces them with many difficult choices and often pushes them to interact with each other. You will be assigning your workers to eleven different locations, such as Tea House, Quarry, Messenger Post, or Barracks, using special Command cards that have additional effects. Production in locations activates ONLY when all their slots are filled, but filling them all by yourself can result in a penalty. On top of that, players can buy overseers who will give additional output every time a location becomes activated. This creates a lot of involving long- and short-term strategies.
       Each player starts with one unique General, characterized by their asymmetric power, as well as the production level. From there, you will further customize your economic engine and fine-tune your strategy by recruiting advisors who provide additional bonuses.
      Eventually, a Wall Defence phase beings, where players place previously build armies on Horde Cards – earning Honor (Victory points) and looting resources from the defeated troops. This requires smart management of three types of units: Archers, Spearmen and Cavalry. Players place these soldiers one by one, playing the Tactics cards that create another layer of interaction.
      Gain meditation by shooting with the Zen Archer, then spend meditation on a Cavalry Squad Leader to move your Cavalry around the battlefield faster, and – finally – finish off by getting extra Honor for each of the Cavalry’s engagements thanks to the Banner Holder. There are endless possibilities for great combos and memorable plays.
      On top of that, your Advisors and General might give your troops extra abilities, such as shooting twice or looting twice the resources!
      All of the above makes the Great Wall one of our most strategically involving designs that will be appreciated by many different groups of players: those who love euro-styled games with their intricate economies and engine-building, those who love over-the-table play, bargaining and negotiations – and finally, those who simply like to wage war on a beautiful map.
       
       
    • By Clearman
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/mystical/space-flesh-bust-collection
       
      Launching on Monday 5/11
       

    • By SparrowMarie
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/gameenvy/desk-wizard-miniature-painting-organizer?ref=discovery&term=desk wizards
  • Who's Online   29 Members, 2 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

×
×
  • Create New...