Jump to content

Sign in to follow this  
Sylverthorne

Impudent Mortal Presents: Mech Cockpit Simulator (Battletech)

Recommended Posts

13 minutes ago, Weird-O said:

Wow, they're not even trying to hide the copyright violations...

 

It's not clear to me that there are any copyright violations.

 

I haven't seen a Battletech box in a while, but IIRC, the record sheets used to be free for copying. When added to the fact that game rules aren't covered by copyright, it might be wise to avoid accusations of tortious conduct.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are two Battletech boxes in print right now, and there's a big difference between photocopying sheets for your own(or your group's) use, and printing those sheets on whatever material he uses to sell them to folks. I'm looking at the record sheet for the Locust right now, and it says 

 

"© The Topps Company, Inc. BattleTech, 'Mech and BattleMech are trademarks of The Topps Company, Inc. All rights reserved. Catalyst Game Labs and the Catalyst Game Labs logo are trademarks of In Media Res, LLC. Permission to photocopy for personal use."

 

I'll admit that it might not necessarily be copyright violation. But if it's not, it's certainly IP theft, or something similar by another name.

Edited by Weird-O

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
47 minutes ago, Weird-O said:

There are two Battletech boxes in print right now, and there's a big difference between photocopying sheets for your own(or your group's) use, and printing those sheets on whatever material he uses to sell them to folks. I'm looking at the record sheet for the Locust right now, and it says 

 

"© The Topps Company, Inc. BattleTech, 'Mech and BattleMech are trademarks of The Topps Company, Inc. All rights reserved. Catalyst Game Labs and the Catalyst Game Labs logo are trademarks of In Media Res, LLC. Permission to photocopy for personal use."

 

I'll admit that it might not necessarily be copyright violation. But if it's not, it's certainly IP theft, or something similar by another name.

 

Only if there is some element to the record sheet that is sufficiently creative to activate the copyright law that is not necessary for play and the project creator doesn't have an agreement to use that element. From the information I have, that does not rise to an obvious violation of IP. Perhaps you have other information from a closer reading of the project information or other, non-public sources.

 

The situation here is very fact specific, which is to say that litigating it would be expensive for all sides and the results would depend on erratic decisions.

 

It's also not clear to me that this project would harm anyone in any way, so there wouldn't be much point to complaining about it on the part of the Battletech IP owner. And it might well help to sell more copies of Battletech.

 

The more interesting question is whether this violates the Trademarks of the game. This is a much closer question to my eyes, but ultimately I think the usage is nominative rather than a violation of the mark.

 

NB: Not a lawyer and this is definitely not legal advice. Talk to a lawyer who is licensed to practice in your area and who specializes in IP law if you want something to act on.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't imagine how they could have the exact same mech name, model number, and correct stats without it being infringing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, Weird-O said:

I can't imagine how they could have the exact same mech name, model number, and correct stats without it being infringing.

 

The same way an aftermarket lightbulb manufacturer can advertise replacement bulbs for the highbeams in a 2014 Toyota Camry LE. It's a nominative use and required rather than optional.

 

Not a slam dunk argument, because that kind of use is, as I noted above, subject to judgement calls on the part of a judge or jury.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm still skeptical, but I'll stop filling up this thread with it so people who like this can get on with the business of liking it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By ratsmitglied
      I'm not associated with these guys, but they make some pretty good MDF terrain, and are branching out into minis
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/knightsofdice/mirrors-of-tullarn-28mm-fantasy-wargaming-miniatures
       
      About
      Mirrors of Tullarn is a new range of 28mm miniatures from Knights of Dice, set in a distinctive fantasy setting and cast in glorious metal!
      These characterful figures have been sculpted by Anton Ducrot (from Flytrap Factory) for tabletop miniature wargames and would look amazing in any fantasy setting, whether that is your Dungeons & Dragons or other roleplaying campaigns or as weary adventurers in your Frostgrave warbands or other tabletop games.
      We are using this campaign to fund the production molds and the initial release of 28 figures from four factions, the Anram, Tarusa, Lahari and Saresh, in glorious white-metal!  Hopefully (with your help!) we can also release a host additional figures in the form of freebies, add-ons and awesome stretch goals!
      A small band of Lahari faces of against some Saresh warriors All the miniatures have been sculpted and master molds created, we simply need the funds to make the production molds to put these figures into full production.
      With your help, we can bring these figures to market and hopefully get a good headstart on expanding the range quickly.
      The Anram defend their mountain hide-away from a marauding band of Tarusa raiders There are 8 simple pledge levels to choose from, we’ve broken them into easy to understand groups. Simply pick a pledge level, (each one represents a group of figures from the different factions), you'll then receive any FREE STRETCH GOALS unlocked during the campaign ... the more stretch goals that are unlocked, the more figures you get for free!
      A group of hired knights accompanied by their paymaster The Wanderer - no rewards, select this pledge to simply show your support!  Thank you!
      The Nomad - back the project at this level and you'll receive the Kickstarter Exclusive 'Void Witch', and gain access to the Add-ons and Stretch Goals to add more when they are unlocked. This pledge does not qualify for any free add-ons.
      Anram Nobility - receive the 7 Anram figures, all FREE stretch goals, access to Add-Ons and the Kickstarter Exclusive figure - the Void Witch!
      Tarusa Chieftain - receive the 7 Tarusa figures, all FREE stretch goals, access to Add-Ons and the Kickstarter Exclusive figure - the Void Witch!
      Lahari Seafarer - receive the 7 Lahari figures, all FREE stretch goals, access to Add-Ons and the Kickstarter Exclusive figure - the Void Witch!
      Saresh Labourer - receive the 7 Saresh figures, all FREE stretch goals, access to Add-Ons and the Kickstarter Exclusive figure - the Void Witch!
      Warlord of Tullarn - You will receive all initial 28 figures from the Anram Nobility, Tarusa Chieftain, Lahari Seafarer & Saresh Labourer  pledges.  You'll also receive all FREE stretch goals, access to add-ons and the Kickstarter Exclusive figure - the Void Witch!
      All-In! - You will receive all 28 figures from the Anram Nobility, Tarusa Chieftain, Lahari Seafarer & Saresh Labourer  pledges.  You'll also receive FOR FREE every unlocked stretch goal, add-on and the Kickstarter Exclusive 'Void Witch'!  This pledge is a little  bit of a gamble, but as the stretch goals start unlocking this pledge level really starts paying dividends!
      *25mm Round slotted base included with every miniature. 
      The masters of time, the Anram live high on the highest peaks across Tullarn Savage mountain clansmen, bent on domination and oppression! Masters of the oceans, rivers and trade the Lahari wear the finest silks and flaunt oppulent treasures Saresh tend to the fertile valleys and vast farmlands of Tullarn A true Warlord knows how to bring people together, and then pitch them at each others throat!
    • By 72moonglum
      So I don't know much about Battletech, more of a fantasy guy myself, but I do like these figures which are some Mech Warriors that were sculpted back in the eighties by Bob Charette that Ral Partha just recently re-released.  They have eight per pack with different poses, and I got these first from the Liao Faction/Clan/Family.  Going to eventually get through the whole group and I'll eventually photograph the whole group together, which is why I haven't based them yet.  I've been told these are the pilots for the Mechs and it's very hot in the cockpit, which is why they are pretty scantily clad.
       

       
      These are eighties Partha, so they are some pretty small  25mm sized figures.  More to come later as I finish them!
       
      Enjoy!
    • By Weird-O
      FINALLY back in a WarShip frame of mind, so here we go! First up is the Essex-class CDS Architeuthis:
       

       
       
      Up next is Alliance Naval Star, consisting of the Nightlord-class CSR Lynn McKenna, Essex-class CSR Marshal Ney and CSR Mulhacén, Whirlwind-class CSR William Adams, and Fredasa-class CSR Kutkh.





    • By joshuaslater
      Cool factions in this game!
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1849625770/chronicles-of-the-wayfarer-heroes
    • By lannister2112
      Here is a Bones inspired kickstarter that I think my fellow painters will appreciate, a travel and display case for your mini. 
      Mini Monument 
      https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/minimonument/mini-monument?ref=nav_search&result=project&term=mini%20monument
       
      Thanks for looking! 
       


  • Who's Online   35 Members, 4 Anonymous, 241 Guests (See full list)

×