Jump to content

Best Star Wars RPG version?


Recommended Posts

I prefer the D6 West End Games version myself. Allot of good gaming memories were done with that system. They even released the main book as a 30th anv edition awhile back.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 31
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

1 hour ago, haldir said:

I prefer the D6 West End Games version myself. Allot of good gaming memories were done with that system. They even released the main book as a 30th anv edition awhile back.

 

Yup. Both by itself and as a two pack with the first sourcebook. Still available in a number of fine hobby shops in this locality.

More than once,  I have wondered how Fantasy Flight felt about the timing of that particular release.

Edited by Dr.Bedlam
  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

I would be leery of FFG after their "revamping" of XWing. Their making everything obsolete to make existing players have to buy updates is not a good sign. Be prepared for them to pull something silly if you go with them. I truly hope I'm wrong as their stuff is really nice.

 

Anybody wanna buy my Gen 1 XWing stuff?

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, kristof65 said:

Explain?

It was FFG that released the anniversary edition. 


It was? I wouldn't have thought they would want to release a product that's in direct competition with their current RPG line.
 

22 minutes ago, Corsair said:

I would be leery of FFG after their "revamping" of XWing. Their making everything obsolete to make existing players have to buy updates is not a good sign. Be prepared for them to pull something silly if you go with them. I truly hope I'm wrong as their stuff is really nice.

 

Anybody wanna buy my Gen 1 XWing stuff?


Ooooh, don't get me started. Another reason I question their decision to release a product that's in direct competition with their existing product...

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Feh... D6 System, D20 System. They all get it wrong.

 

They even tell you in the movie 'Use D4s, Luke!' :zombie:

 

The Auld Grump -- seriously, there was a lot of good material for the D6 version - so much so that it was used by Disney when making the new movies. (I swear to Gogamagog, Rogue 1 felt so very much like an RPG....)

 

*EDIT* Never ran it - any edition. But I did play the Miniatures game, which was a lot of fun.

Edited by TheAuldGrump
  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney was not the first to use the D6 Star Wars RPG. Lucasfilm used them while creating the prequels and Clone Wars.  
 

The D6 books were the source of allot of the species, planet, and weapon names.  
 

Pablo Hidalgo was a writer for the D6 stuff and is currently a part of the Lucasfilm Story group.  Which is why things like the Rogue One,  Rebels, and the Mandalorian feel so much like the D6 stuff. 

  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

Author Timothy Zahn, creator of Admiral Thrawn (one of the greatest Star Wars villains) tells a story about how, when he was a young author hot off a few early successes, he was engaged to write some Star Wars Expanded Universe novels.

Zahn freely admitted that while he had seen the movies, he wasn't really a massive fanboy, and did they have a story bible or something?

Lucasfilm sent him a box of West End Games Star Wars D6 sourcebooks.

And Zahn read them, and that's what he used for background when he wrote his books. Zahn's books are generally credited with kicking off the whole Expanded Universe literature boom, and Admiral Thrawn eventually made his way into modern canon by appearing in the animated Star Wars Rebels show.

Unrelated note: The SW collectible card game included his character Talon Karrde, the rakish rogue and criminal. Zahn was the model for the illustration.

  • Like 7
Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Dr.Bedlam said:

Unrelated note: The SW collectible card game included his character Talon Karrde, the rakish rogue and criminal. Zahn was the model for the illustration.

 

The Decipher one?? If so, I'll have to look that up as I have every card from every set in that one. Thou I may be missing a few of the last sets but I doubt it.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, haldir said:

 

The Decipher one?? If so, I'll have to look that up as I have every card from every set in that one. Thou I may be missing a few of the last sets but I doubt it.

 

I've never seen the card in question, but the trivia's from Wookieepedia. Supposedly, Zahn needed hair extensions to complete the look....

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, haldir said:

 

The Decipher one?? If so, I'll have to look that up as I have every card from every set in that one. Thou I may be missing a few of the last sets but I doubt it.

 

Yes.  I think.

 

Found an image from Google and (C) on the card is 2000, but there seem to be multiple cards with Karrde although his appearance is consistent.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

ffg's system is fun
you only need one of the core books to play, but will get restricted mostly to a theme
2 dice sets works pretty well

if you need to play with minis
the legion core set, while not cheap,  includes a pretty nice amount of generic rebels and stormtroopers for an age of rebellion game

Link to post
Share on other sites

Late to the party, but I would say that the 3rd edition of the WEG Star Wars RPG is the best version (epecially with some of the supplements - I really like the encumbrace system they came up with in one of those books). I even did a mod of the 3rd edition to play a short-lived HALO RPG (the players were just marines in the setting, not Spartans). WEG also did a generic set of books for their d6 game system called d6 Adventure, d6 Fantasy and d6 Space. Easy enough to tweak them to fit back into the Star Wars setting if you can't get the original SW books (I'm pretty sure you can stiill get all the generic d6 system books).

Link to post
Share on other sites

I believe that I've played pretty much all of the versions, though most of the WEG stuff was owned by other people in the group and I've only played a few demo games of the FFG one (Disney era Star Wars hasn't interested me that much...keep considering going back for some of the other things, don't have Disney+ and only enjoyed Rogue One though it annoyed me that it was basically an everyone dies version of the prologue part of Dark Forces). I enjoyed the 3 versions using the D20 system, though the OCR/RCR stuff had some major issues...I really liked Saga Edition and have used it for non-Star Wars games. I also played both simplified ones based on D20 (The one in the downloadable demo game and the old Starter one).

 

Saga Edition is very easy to pick up and, if you play D&D, you pretty much have all of the stuff you need with the core book and a few character sheets. You can add a whole lot more with extra books, but the core is basically all you need.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By R2ED
      Got it based and finished.  Hooray! 
       

    • By R2ED
      I bought this little model at a local game store that had it in the clearance bin.  I thought it looked cool, I love Star Wars, so why not buy it?  However, a year ago, I wasn't at the level to paint it.  I primed it.  Based it.  And then let it sit for a loooooong time on the shelf without touching it.  
       
      Today was the day.
       
       

       
      BATTLE REPORT!
       
      This was a great model for me to test layers on.  Over the last 4 models I've painted, I've really picked up a new rhythm and life for painting, which feels so good to get some wind back in my sails.  I still have to finish the desert-ish base for Greedo, but I think his paint job looks solid.
       
      Wins:
      * Keeping my palette of colors out and planned helped so much!  I've picked my layering colors, laid them out in the wet palette and am saving time.  
      *  Mixing colors is also much easier by keeping similar tones.  In his vest, and arm/pant panels, I used leather as the base.  In his pants and jacket, I used a stormy gray to highlight up.  
      *  Alien Flesh!!!  I've been sitting on this color, I don't know how long.  I was thinking, "Gosh, if only I had a light green that would work with an alie...OH MY GOD!
      *  Learning my own recipe of water-to-paint ratios to allow for washes feels great!  Gives my painting more flexibility.
      *  Eyes.  When they are that big, it makes it pretty easy to do them.  I need to work on the reflections still, but I am happy with them.  Using Indigo Blue and up to Rich Indigo then mixing in white up to white.  Works.
       
      Misses:
      *  Got sloppy twice and ended up swiping leather color over my pants and jacket 2 times.  Thankfully I could catch and fix, but it was a few 'choice words' I may have said when I did it.  
      *  Used a blue tack for the handle I was using and unfortunately, it didn't stick as well to my homemade metal base.  It nearly fell into the paint palette.  He nearly ended up as messy as my shorts.  I nearly crapped myself.  Also followed by more choice words.
      *  I tried using brown liner around the jacket and separation in the pockets on the vest, but it just didn't work like I had hoped.  I need to learn how to darken in a similar color without going too dark and stark of a change.  
       
      Would love to hear your feedback.  Let me know what you think can be improved or worked on.  I appreciate any and all comments.
       
      Here's my process photos and my inspiration image.
       


       

       

       

       

       

       
       
    • By strawhat
      Lots of pictures.  I've done my best to keep the size down.
       
      The Cast:
       
      Story:
      In the waning days of the Galactic Rebellion, before the Battle of Yavin and Scariff, the Empire had nearly wiped out not only the Jedi but also many users of The Force.  Emperor Palpatine had special hunters, known as Inquisitors, that scoured the galaxy and captured/killed those rogues that survived Order 66.
       
      The Grand Inquisitor tracked another Force user to the remote Tibana gas mine known as Cloud City hovering in the Bespin atmosphere.  The Inquisitor had orders to capture the rogue and return him to the Emperor for purposes unknown.  After setting up a carbon-freezing chamber in the depths of the city, the Inquisitor set his plan into motion.  Hired muscle, in the form of notorious Trandoshan bounty hunter Bossk, would help drive Hawkbat to the chamber into the waiting trap manned by Agent Blaise and two Imperial Security Bureau agents.
       
      The large sums of money thrown around by the Empire aroused the suspicions of vile gangster Jabba the Hutt who, despite his long residency on Tatooine, has decided to make a rare off-world trip to witness the hunt.  Bringing along a trusted, if slow on the draw, bounty hunter known as Greedo.  Jabba would attempt to maneuver the happenings to his own advantage.
       
      Agent Hawkbat, despite being useful on many occasions to Cloud City administrator Lando Calrissean, had run out of allies there.  Unbeknownst to him, Obi-Wan Kenobi had picked up his lightsaber once more and sought to foil the Inquisitor's plans.  After contacting an old friend, Ithorian Diplomat Murne Rin, the two would seek aid from the Administrator--If Hawkbat were no longer in Cloud City the Imperials would likely leave.  The Tibana gas mined here was not of sufficient quantity or quality to warrant further action by the Empire, and the Inquisitor seemed to barely notice anything not directly related to his quarry.
       
      But could Obi-Wan and Murne count on Calrissean's aid, or would he betray them all to Imperial forces?
       
      It appears that I've missed the rings on a couple bases.  I'll have to go back, one of these days, and tidy those up.
       
       
    • By strawhat
      The Cast:
       
      The Story:
       
      After the capture of Han Solo by the Bounty Hunter Boba Fett, Princess Leia Organa selects a group of operatives to accompany her on a special mission back to Hoth in order to recover files and equipment that will be necessary to implement Solo's rescue.  The rebels expected the remains of the base to be empty, but Darth Vader's prescience led him to leave a small garrison force on the remote ice planet.  
       
      Dengar, and his cadre of assassin droids, were too late to Bespin to participate in Solo's capture and the attempted capture of Luke Skywalker, but he continued trailing the Millenium Falcon when it left Cloud City.  Unfortunately for Dengar, the rebel sniper Loku Kanoloa trailed the rest of the band and now has the bounty hunter in his sights.
       
      The rebels managed to acquire their assets but were discovered on their way out of the base.  General Sorin, eager to not fail Darth Vader, has deployed all his best assets in an effort to capture the rebels before they can return to their transport and escape.
       
      All the activity in the area of the base has alerted a small band of wampas that were living in the ruins, and they are investigating.
       
       
      Again, I need to redo some of the Scum & Villainy bases.  I think I changed ring-colors and the darker green just doesn't show well.
       
      Dengar's armor is the wrong color.  I was originally going to do more of a feldbruan, but I got caught mentally on feldgrau.  I also need to go over the dots on the HK's bases.  I was originally going to mark the bases to distinguish which tokens to use, but I came up with a better way (as many IA gamers/painters did) of just hitting the base with a hash mark in the appropriate color.  That makes it much easier to distinguish which models go together and which ones are which.
       
      Loku is shown in the printed materials as being a red Mon Calamari wearing green.  But, after Rogue One introduced to Admiral Raddus and his crew, I knew I didn't want to paint him red.  It makes no (visual) sense for a sniper on an ice world to be wearing so much brown and green, so I went rogue and painted him blue with  more lighter colored gear.  I thought about painting his skin white, but...
       
      so...
       
      much...
       
      white...
       
      I just couldn't do it (and I still have 11 or so characters who will be wearing white)!  I think I should have started with a little bit lighter shade, but I did what I did and I'm not redoing it or Dengar's armor.  It might not be accurate, but tough noogies.
    • By strawhat
      I finished Hera a few days ago, then Chopper earlier today, and finally the Dewback Rider this evening!
       
      I'm not feeling up to writing out a little story or dragging out the tiles for the game, so it's straight up pictures.  Even the pictures are lacking in quality tonight with too much light and bad focal ranges.  Still, you'll get the idea.
       


       
      Regular and Elite Jet Troopers.  FFG sent two flight pegs with each base, but honestly that's a lot of height.  Although I admit I thought about having the Elites on two pegs.
       


       
      Regular and Elite Gamorrean Guards.  I varied the colors on the fur pants and through their skin tones.
       


       
      Weequay Pirates.  Again the skin tones and uniform colors were tweaked a bit.  The rifles are a bit flimsier than they look.  I just about broke one by accident.
       



       
      In order: Onar Kona (an Aqualish bodyguard), Shyla Verad (Mandalorian bounty hunter), and Vinto Hreeda (Rodian gunslinger).
       
      The art has Onar as green, but I defaulted to blue and by the time I realized my mistake it was too late.  Onar is one of the rarer four-eyed Aqualish.
      I used the Twilight Purples for Shyla.  I'd been looking for an excuse to use that set.  Her cloak is grey-white and the Beskar shines brightly.
      Vinto was a bit of a splurge in terms of colors I wanted to use.  A little louder than most Rodians we see, but I don't think it's outlandish.  I'm going to have to get back to "regular" green for Rodians pretty soon when I get back to "Hired Guns."
       


       
      I wanted one Dewback for each configuration, so I've got the regular rider and Captain Terro.  The regular dewback is a little lighter than I wanted, but I think it works well enough.  Captain Terro's dewback is based on a lizard I saw in the central part of the state.  I originally dropped the first Terro torso and snapped the tip of his flamethrower straight off.  I was not happy.
       

       
      The Jawa Scavenger (or Luke Skywalker, Jedi Knight) might well count as my first speed paint!  Only about an hour and a half on it, and I think it looks like a solid enough job for tabletop.
       

       
      Jabba the Hutt.  We saw him back in The Bespin Gambit, but this is his home.  Easy enough job, lots of drybrushing.  I started trying to highlight, but quickly realized that the skin texture would lend itself to the drybrush well enough.
       

       
      Alliance Rangers.  I was surprised when I realized that they were women (you pretty much have to look up from under the arm or straight down from the top to notice).  The rifle gets in the way of the painting.
       

       
      Luke Skywalker, Jedi Knight.  I used Muddy Soil to bring up the black on the jump suit.  The tunic is a grey.  The lightsaber blade is too short, and the handle too long.  Nothing I can do about those things with my current skill set.  Luke was another speed paint, or close to it.  I tell you, finishing two minis in under five hours made me feel like a king!
       

       
      C1-10P (aka Chopper, aka Spectre 3) and Hera Syndulla (aka Spectre 2).  I'm not that into Rebels...It's kind of fun and fluffy.  And that lack of engagement has hurt my ability to focus and get things done on these two.  Plus there was more green, and as a rule I do not much care for green.  I used one of the bone triads on Chopper as I felt his age and general bad attitude would keep him a bit dingy.  Hera's not quite the right shade of green, and I should have really worked some freehand circles for the designs on her lekku, but I think it works.  
       

       
      Which leaves us at the Rancor.  This thing's huge.  The base is a little undersized at about 2.5" x 1.75" (instead of the full 3"x2" that it should be).  It went faster than I thought.  I used two different brown triads on the Rancor, one for the "armor" plates and the other for the flesh.  It's tough to see in the picture, but it's more obvious in person.
       
      Up next: Ahsoka Tano and the AT-DP from Heart of the Empire or the nagendra from Bones IV.  Decisions, decisions.
       
      Thanks for stopping by!
       
      PS:
      I forgot about BT-1 and 0-0-0.  They were done, but even though I actually picked them up, I forgot to include them.  D'Oh!


  • Who's Online   7 Members, 0 Anonymous, 20 Guests (See full list)

×
×
  • Create New...